Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

1,936 notes

2016

Scarecrow Cabernet Sauvignon

Napa Valley · Rutherford

This was the first wine in the tasting that seemed less uptight and unyielding. Here, a plushness and savoriness shows. A bit fruity at first, but with a textual seamlessness that seems to indicate a…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

MacDonald Cabernet Sauvignon

Napa Valley · Oakville

On first pass, and during the blind portion of this tasting, this presents as somewhat reduced, with muted fruit; it shows as both rounder and drier on the finish (if that's possible?). Shy red fruit…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2019

MacDonald Cabernet Sauvignon

Napa Valley · Oakville

This was not part of the blind tasting of 2016 Napa Cabs, but of course, and you know how these things go, due to the continuing graciousness of our hosts, this 2019 MacDonald found its way into the…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2019

La Pelle Cabernet Sauvignon Alluvium

Napa Valley · St. Helena

Another go-around with this wine, which delivered the initial hit of powerful tannins, but was able to find a nice groove once given a healthy amount of air. This bottle kicked out super dark, black…

Reviewed 30 April 2023
2016

Roam Cabernet Sauvignon Sleeping Lady Vineyard

Napa Valley · Yountville

A very plush rendering of Sleeping Lady, with mocha, blueberries, blackberry cobbler, milk chocolate, vanilla, and sweet cassis, the 2016 Roam is succulent and round, with an easily accessible…

Reviewed 30 April 2023
2018

Promontory

California · Napa Valley

So chiseled and linear that it almost seems like this thing is gonna stayed locked and loaded for the next 30 years. With air, air, air, and more air, blackberry seed, black cherry, and fresh herbs…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2016

Adamvs Cabernet Sauvignon Quintvs

Napa Valley · Howell Mountain

Hands-down my favorite Quintvs of the lineup, with a depth and purity that truly delivers all the goods with one gorgeous gulp. The 2016s at this address are phenomenal, and the Quintvs showcases it…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2016

Promontory

California · Napa Valley

A perfect wine. And in 10 years it'll be a perfect wine. And in 15 years it'll be a perfect wine. And in 20 years it'll..well, you get the picture. So, we all know that taro card reading wine is an…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2015

Adamvs Cabernet Sauvignon Quintvs

Napa Valley · Howell Mountain

Well, I asked for some tension and I got some tension. The 2015 is tighter and more linear than the 2014. This is indeed a long-hauler, with quite the grippy frame. More herbal and exacting on the…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2010

Promontory

California · Napa Valley

There is a simmering herbaceous energy that swarms around the black currant and unripe black cherry flavors, with menthol and forest floor rounding out the profile. The cooler vintage makes for a…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2014

Adamvs Cabernet Sauvignon Quintvs

Napa Valley · Howell Mountain

A noticeable step up from the Teres, the Quintvs (pronounced Quintus, by the way - this house uses the "v" as a "u" FYI. A helpful hint from your pal csimm so you don't walk around saying "Adam-vs"…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2020

Promontory

California · Napa Valley

I didn't get much of a read here. It was so linear and primary that any sort of logical assessment was lost between the pucker and the frame. Sour cherry and sour cherry and sour cherry. The finish…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2018

Adamvs Cabernet Sauvignon Teres

Napa Valley · Howell Mountain

Along the same lines as the 2016, this 2018 has a fuller mouthfeel and some dark power to counterbalance the grainy frame. The 2018 displays some of the mineral-inflect tannic spine as the 2013, but…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2019

La Pelle Cabernet Sauvignon Reserve

California · Napa Valley

Surely the best of the bunch in terms of concentration and depth, the Reserve Cabernet offers that extra layer of density and breadth befitting a reserve designation. Powerful blackberry, black…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2016

Adamvs Cabernet Sauvignon Teres

Napa Valley · Howell Mountain

The vintage here does the Teres all the favors in the world, with initially a tight front end, but with requisite power to throttle the fruit and push it forward so that it can compete with the…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2019

La Pelle Cabernet Sauvignon Alluvium

Napa Valley · St. Helena

The powerhouse of the three SVDs, the Alluvium elbows past the partygoers and shows its upfront opulence and swanky luxury. Ripe blackberry is encircled with a bit of booze on the initial cascade of…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2013

Adamvs Cabernet Sauvignon Teres

Napa Valley · Howell Mountain

Tight, linear, and a bit spicy, the 2013 Teres shows some of the stern hallmarks of the vintage. With air, red and black currants, herbs, unripe raspberries, and dusty earth emerge. Finishes with…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2019

La Pelle Cabernet Sauvignon Ceniza

Napa Valley · Coombsville

Comparatively darker and chewier than the Red Hen, The Ceniza rolls out the blackberry, ash, bitter chocolate, pulverized granite, pencil lead, and wet cave flavors with a gothic and semi-serious…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2019

001 Vintners Cabernet Sauvignon Ecotone Vineyard

California · Napa Valley

A new project by Jack Bittner, with Graeme Macdonald as winemaker, the 2019 001 (double-O[oh]-one) will be the inaugural wine from prime plots on the Ecotone site. Jack was gracious enough to meet us…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2019

La Pelle Cabernet Sauvignon Red Hen Vineyard

Napa Valley · Oak Knoll District

Dark and deep, with ripe blackberry, purple plum, and red and black raspberry notes almost immediately landing on the mid-palate with a perfect dollop of savory goodness, but also with red currant…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2014

Tusk Estates Cabernet Sauvignon

California · Napa Valley

Huh. This was. initially pretty perplexing. Round and uber-plush. Displayed pretty yummy black and blue fruit that was indeed tasty, but lacked the extra frame and tension to keep things moving and…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2016

Adamvs Cabernet Sauvignon Estate

Napa Valley · Howell Mountain

Another bottle of this got thrown into the mix courtesy of Cristal2000. This bottle OWNED the table in its own right. A Howell Mountain beauty that really outshined its other Adamvs peers all the way…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2019

La Pelle Cabernet Sauvignon

California · Napa Valley

If you have $85 burning a hole in your corduroys and don't know what to spend it on, might I suggest the La Pelle Napa Valley. This is a total bang for your buck wine. You can drink this now and not…

Reviewed 7 April 2023