Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

218 notes

2010

Thomas Fogarty Syrah Fat Buck Ridge Vineyard

California · Santa Cruz Mountains

Dead and lifeless. Stewed plum, pepper, barnyard. Serving this as part of a Signature Reserve Tasting was insulting to say the least. Not even worth commenting further on.

Reviewed 4 November 2016
2012

Pruett Vineyards Syrah Taylor's Reserve

Sierra Foothills · Placer County

All previous notes apply. This was tasted next to a 2012 Boich Cabernet GIII and a 2013 Myriad Cabernet, which both bested the Pruett. Not exactly a fair fight.

Reviewed 1 November 2016
2012

DuMOL Syrah Jack Robert's Run

Sonoma County · Sonoma Coast

A very "friendly" Syrah, with easily accessible notes of blackberry and blueberry, with smoke and floral hints framing out the core fruit.

Reviewed 23 October 2016
2014

Boich Family Cellar Syrah Wall Road Terrace

Napa Valley · Mt. Veeder

The first of four wines poured. This was understandably tight and a little lithe for a California Syrah. Some of the mountain fruit was evident, with hints of bramble and minerality surrounding the…

Reviewed 22 October 2016
2012

Pruett Vineyards Syrah Taylor's Reserve

Sierra Foothills · Placer County

Still about the same as my notes from last year. A very well-made Syrah, especially for the price-point. Not sure time will really move this into any further significant or elevated flavor profile;…

Reviewed 21 October 2016
2010

Booker Vineyard Syrah Fracture

Central Coast · Paso Robles

Same as my notes from last year, except that this still needs more time. Drank "fine" after a couple of hours in a wide-bottomed decanter, but was still a little tight. Good purity of fruit. Not a…

Reviewed 14 October 2016
2010

Carlisle Syrah Sonoma County

California · Sonoma County

Same as previous notes. Some ok plum and blackberry notes. Nothing much beyond that. Last bottle.

Reviewed 5 October 2016
2011

Alban Vineyards Syrah Reva Alban Estate Vineyard

Central Coast · Edna Valley

Not exactly ready for prime time just yet, but surely showing promise of good things to come. I wouldn't recommend touching another one of these bottles for at least a year. Let it fatten up and fan…

Reviewed 30 September 2016
2005

Salinia Syrah Heintz Ranch

Sonoma County · Sonoma Coast

Saline-driven syrah, with muted purple berry notes and a little wood. Nothing complex at this stage. A bit of a dud. I'm probably the only one on the planet who actually had a bottle of this left…

Reviewed 24 September 2016
2012

Keplinger Diamond Bar

Sierra Foothills · Fair Play

Tight and totally balled-up through the entire 4+ hours of tasting (decanted in a wide-bottomed decanter for most of that time at 54 degrees - warming it up in the glass to more room temperature…

Reviewed 10 September 2016
2014

TOR Syrah Rogers La Herradura

California · Napa Valley

Like the Grenache, this Syrah came off a bit thin mid-palate. Undeniably young, and a step up from the Grenache for sure, this Syrah was in serious need of sleep time. Not astringent or tannic; just…

Reviewed 27 August 2016
2010

Alban Vineyards Syrah Reva Alban Estate Vineyard

Central Coast · Edna Valley

WAIT on this wine! Decanted for over three hours, showing signs of those top shelf Alban flavors of black raspberry, olive, and charred/bbq. However, it's not quite there yet. This 2010 was quite…

Reviewed 19 August 2016
2012

Carlisle Syrah Papa's Block

Sonoma County · Russian River Valley

Same as my notes from February 2016. 93+. A decent drink now with a short decant or hold for another year.

Reviewed 9 August 2016
2010

Cayuse Syrah Bionic Frog

Columbia Valley · Walla Walla Valley

PnP with signature Cayuse notes of beef jerky, hot brick, terra cotta, black cherry, plum, river rock, and saline. After about an hour in the decanter, the flavors deepened a bit, but the wine didn't…

Reviewed 25 July 2016
2013

Carlisle Syrah Sonoma County

California · Sonoma County

PnP with classic notes of dark berry fruit, berry liqueur, red and black cherry, and hints of white pepper, sanguine, and spice.

Reviewed 20 July 2016
2010

Carlisle Syrah Sonoma County

California · Sonoma County

Same notes as 12/25/2015. 88-89 points. Served alongside a 2010 Saxum Booker and 2010 Tor Reserve ROCK Syrah. The Saxum blew the others out of the water for me. Not decanted. Didn't need it. Flat and…

Reviewed 25 June 2016
2009

Cayuse Syrah En Chamberlin Vineyard

Columbia Valley · Walla Walla Valley

If this is supposed to taste like horse manure and sour cherries, then "Bravo" to Christophe Baron. Otherwise, this better have been flawed.

Reviewed 31 May 2016
2010

Carlisle Syrah Papa's Block

Sonoma County · Russian River Valley

Same as my specific notes from 8/19/2015. My last bottle. Ended up being a good Syrah with a very good QPR. Nothing earth-shattering, but a pleasant drink nonetheless. Papa's Block is consistently…

Reviewed 26 May 2016
2009

Alban Vineyards Syrah Reva Alban Estate Vineyard

Central Coast · Edna Valley

PnP with amazing ready-to-go flavors of deep, exotic red, purple, and black berry fruit, black raspberry liqueur, beautiful charred oak and scorched earth, olive tapenade (but not the overly salty…

Reviewed 18 May 2016
2012

Carlisle Syrah Rosella's Vineyard

Central Coast · Santa Lucia Highlands

Notes of flashy purple and red berry fruit, brush, and some alcohol and vanilla. Fairly simple and straightforward, but a pleasant enough sipper throughout the evening. Nothing I would necessarily…

Reviewed 9 May 2016
2012

Pruett Vineyards Syrah Championship Cuvee

California · Sierra Foothills

Same as my notes from 1/18/2016. Good solid Syrah. Impeccably balanced with a silky texture and nice core fruit flavors.

Reviewed 4 May 2016
2009

Domaine Auguste Clape Cornas

Northern Rhône · Cornas

This was clearly not ready on the initial PnP, with tight, palate-puckering notes of chalky purple and red berry fruit, asphalt, wet hay, and earth.

Reviewed 5 April 2016
2014

Carlisle Syrah Rosella's Vineyard

Central Coast · Santa Lucia Highlands

MATT SCOTT nailed it again with many of the specific tasting notes on this wine. Flavors of elderberry, blueberry, blackberry, violets, limestone, and earth. It almost tasted to me as though there…

Reviewed 2 April 2016
2010

Sine Qua Non Syrah Five Shooter

California · Central Coast

PnP with notes of ripe (reductive) plum, saline, amarena fabbri wild black cherry, ripe cranberry, hot brick, terra cotta, worn leather, brush, and a hint of vanilla. Fanned out nicely over the…

Reviewed 1 April 2016