Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

5,921 notes

2008

Egly-Ouriet Champagne Grand Cru Brut Millésimé

Champagne · Grand Cru

Initially, there are strong oxidative and nutty notes emanating from this Egly, but with air, it actually becomes more compacted and focused, with requisite cut and acidic tension to balance out the…

Reviewed 6 June 2023
2006

Salon Champagne Blanc de Blancs Brut

France · Champagne

If a Sade smoooooth operator kind of vibe is what you long for in your Champagne, then bust out this charming bewitcher and let the good times roll. This highwire act gets a ton of points for its…

Reviewed 6 June 2023
2018

Colgin Cabernet Sauvignon Tychson Hill Vineyard

California · Napa Valley

Saturating, juicy, delectable, and all the superlatives you can conjure up to describe what is indeed the most giving of the bunch. Heightened complexity is temporarily on hold during the initial…

Reviewed 2 June 2023
2016

MacDonald Cabernet Sauvignon

Napa Valley · Oakville

Speaking of proper service, having this wine a couple of weeks ago and having it again now just shows how important knowing (or attempting to target) a wine's sweet spot in terms of air, temperature,…

Reviewed 2 June 2023
2018

Harlan Estate

Napa Valley · Oakville

At first pass, this is a crunchy unripe black cherry covered in salty sawdust. I recall having that "Uh-Oh" feeling, wondering, "What wine is this? Did someone throw in a pirate here??" It doesn't…

Reviewed 2 June 2023
2018

Promontory

California · Napa Valley

Though the oak here is perceptible, it does not show as aggressively as Harlan on the initial pull of the cork. Earth, eucalyptus (or is it bay leaf?... or is it mint??), grippy unripe blackberry and…

Reviewed 2 June 2023
2019

MacDonald Cabernet Sauvignon

Napa Valley · Oakville

This was not part of the blind tasting of 2016 Napa Cabs, but of course, and you know how these things go, due to the continuing graciousness of our hosts, this 2019 MacDonald found its way into the…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

Vice Versa Cabernet Sauvignon The Magnificent Seven

California · Napa Valley

Black earth, soil, black cherry, blackberry, and a slight vanillin chocolate note, this was the most succulent and deep wine in the lineup. It shows cascading opulence without being overdone. The…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

Colgin Cabernet Sauvignon Tychson Hill Vineyard

California · Napa Valley

Juicy and rich, with black fruit dominating the profile, the Colgin Tychson was quite the giving specimen. I suspected it might be a Colgin, but went with believing it was the M7 (erroneous as that…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

Futo Oakville

Napa Valley · Oakville

An awesome combination of fresh and brooding. I love the interplay of flavors here, with blackberries and purple plums dancing with the black minerality and meaty saline notes. I waffled between…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

Eisele Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon

California · Napa Valley

Red and black fruit, expressive but tannic on the back end, finishing dry but not without requisite flavor and length. With air, the layering continued, though it was a bit unresolved and slightly…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

BOND St. Eden

California · Napa Valley

Deep and rich, but with a black fruited and mineral cut that starts out angular but quickly moves into a nice combination of grippy and giving. This is an interesting wine in that it starts out…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

Scarecrow Cabernet Sauvignon

Napa Valley · Rutherford

This was the first wine in the tasting that seemed less uptight and unyielding. Here, a plushness and savoriness shows. A bit fruity at first, but with a textual seamlessness that seems to indicate a…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

MacDonald Cabernet Sauvignon

Napa Valley · Oakville

On first pass, and during the blind portion of this tasting, this presents as somewhat reduced, with muted fruit; it shows as both rounder and drier on the finish (if that's possible?). Shy red fruit…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

Colgin IX Estate

California · Napa Valley

Compared to wine before it in the lineup (which was a red-"fruited" [mostly tannic] Abreu Thorevilos), this was all about black fruit, bitter chocolate, and black minerality. Did I mention black?…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

Abreu Thorevilos

California · Napa Valley

Red, powerful, tannic, and dry, with a woody finish that makes for an arid exit. A salty olive brine note adds to the initial feeling of astringency. With air, menthol, gravel, and unripe red cherry…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2019

Domaine de Montille Meursault 1er Cru Les Perrières

Côte de Beaune · Meursault 1er Cru

Don't have a healthy pour of the Montille Perrieres Mearsault handily in front of you at the moment? Well then, light a match, shove the head up your nose, and spin it around until the sulfur is…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2019

Domaine de Montille Puligny-Montrachet 1er Cru Les Folatières

Côte de Beaune · Puligny-Montrachet 1er Cru

Muted and linear upon the first pull of the cork, the Montille Folatieres grabs you by the ears with freshness and crisp focus but is reluctant to show the goods on the initial shake-and-wake hour or…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2006

Krug Champagne Vintage Brut

France · Champagne

Though I haven't been thoroughly stoked on a ton of 2006 Champagne as of late, I gotta tell ya that this bottle of Krug was in a really beautiful spot. Oxidative and a little brooding (sure, it's a…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2008

Louis Roederer Champagne Cristal Brut

France · Champagne

Wine is funny. More specifically, BOTTLES of wine are funny. When I first took a stab at the 2008 Cristal a while back, I found it to be a "very good," "fine," "a solid 94" (which is nothing to scoff…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2013

Philipponnat Champagne Extra Brut Clos des Goisses

France · Champagne

A great showing, and one where the spiciness and energy are on full display. A lot of things going on here, with a slightly darker profile than I was expecting. The color was like a pale Rosé with…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
NV

Egly-Ouriet Champagne Grand Cru VP

Champagne · Grand Cru

On the initial pull of the cork, the flavors play coy for the first hour or so of consumption. Red and yellow apple flesh, grilled lemon, and wet granite notes take their time leisurely disembarking…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2020

Sine Qua Non Distenta White II

California · Central Coast

In typical Sine Qua Non fashion, the white in this vintage is a fetching Frankenstein concoction of 32% Roussanne, 26% Viognier, 25% Chardonnay, 12% Gelber Muskateller (so. basically Muscat), and 5%…

Reviewed 1 June 2023