Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

48 notes

2018

Carlisle Syrah Radiant Ridge

Sonoma County · Bennett Valley

Primary and fairly straight forward right now, with a linear expression of the varietal. Unripe crunchy plum, pomegranate seed, Concord grape, and raspberry seed dominate the profile. Next-to-no…

Reviewed 21 February 2022
2018

Carlisle Mourvèdre Radiant Ridge

Sonoma County · Bennett Valley

Pouring a translucent purple-crimson, the 2018 Carlisle Radiant Ridge Mourvèdre rockets-up aromas of spring flowers and a medley of freshly washed berries and cherries. The intoxicating color and…

Reviewed 20 September 2021
2014

Carlisle Petite Sirah Palisades Vineyard

California · Napa Valley

Nearly three years ago I had this from barrel and it showed tremendous promise. Now having been in bottle a few years, this wine is certainly on its way to becoming a beautiful representation of the…

Reviewed 8 October 2018
2013

Carlisle Syrah Sonoma County

California · Sonoma County

This wine showed pretty flat compared to April 2018 when I last had it. This was also served next to a '12 Favia Quarzo, which bested it by a margin. It was fine, but nothing memorable here. Some…

Reviewed 14 September 2018
2013

Carlisle Syrah Sonoma County

California · Sonoma County

Much improved since I last had this wine 1.5 years ago. Dark purple and black core fruit, with notes of black pepper, camphor, black olive, and some subtle spice. Beautifully balanced with a…

Reviewed 29 April 2018
2013

Carlisle Petite Sirah Sonoma County

California · Sonoma County

As others have noted, this needs some time to deepen its flavor profile and get out of its flatter, linear delivery. Still maintained fairly good balance, with some higher toned red and purple berry…

Reviewed 16 April 2018
2015

Carlisle Zinfandel Carlisle Vineyard

Sonoma County · Russian River Valley

Ok...I'll take the incoming arrows on this one. Apparently I'm missing something here. I found this to be a higher-register, linear, sour example of the varietal. Yes, it's young, but the lack of…

Reviewed 14 April 2018
2012

Carlisle Syrah Rosella's Vineyard

Central Coast · Santa Lucia Highlands

Same as two months ago. I had to go back to drinking a KB Pinot Noir (which was barely memorable as it was) just to get some flavor going back on my palate. Not too encouraging when a forgettable…

Reviewed 2 December 2017
2012

Carlisle Syrah Sierra Mar Vineyard Santa Lucia Highlands

Central Coast · Santa Lucia Highlands

Red and purple fruit, with faint passings-by of olive, railroad tie, and asphalt. Not overly complex or concentrated, with the mid-palate leaving something to be desired. One could hold this for…

Reviewed 15 November 2017
2012

Carlisle Syrah Rosella's Vineyard

Central Coast · Santa Lucia Highlands

Linear and flat across the palate from start to finish. Some purple berry fruit and fleeting hits of black olive (like the kind on a Roundtable pizza). Lackluster indeed (and not "off" in terms of…

Reviewed 15 October 2017
2012

Carlisle Syrah Papa's Block

Sonoma County · Russian River Valley

Same as 2+ months ago. Some blasé, medium-bodied flavors of blackberry, plum, black cherry, and faint vanilla. Kinda fruity overall in the initial attack, but faded extremely fast on the back end. A…

Reviewed 23 August 2017
2012

Carlisle Syrah Papa's Block

Sonoma County · Russian River Valley

Some of my previous notes apply. Not a particularly noteworthy showing this time around. PnP was tight and predominantly alcohol and acid based. The fruit was reserved, hidden under a tannic clamp…

Reviewed 9 June 2017
2009

Carlisle Petite Sirah Sonoma County

California · Sonoma County

Same as my notes from six months ago. Decanted a total of three hours, which helped. There is definitely a spine left in it for sure, and enough grip to keep the frame solid throughout consumption.…

Reviewed 21 March 2017
2012

Carlisle Syrah James Berry Vineyard

Central Coast · Paso Robles

Previous notes apply. Hold until 2018. Came off a little sweet and disjointed initially. Opened up a bit more after a few hours in the decanter, but was still a little too plush and round for my…

Reviewed 17 December 2016
2013

Carlisle Syrah Sonoma County

California · Sonoma County

Previous notes apply. A good Syrah for $25, and yes, that qualifier needs to be there. It drinks above its price point in the sense that it is super inexpensive. But it doesn't drink way above its…

Reviewed 5 December 2016
2009

Carlisle Petite Sirah Sonoma County

California · Sonoma County

A very beautiful example of the varietal; in a near-perfect drinking window. Displaying finessed flavors of black raspberry, blackberry, purple berry/plum, and hints of blueberry. Subtle asphalt…

Reviewed 22 November 2016
2012

Carlisle Syrah Papa's Block

Sonoma County · Russian River Valley

Same as previous notes. Some subtle black olive and earth notes after about 3 hours in the decanter at 54 degrees. I will try to hold until mid/late 2017.

Reviewed 8 November 2016
2009

Carlisle Petite Sirah Palisades Vineyard

California · Napa Valley

Previous notes apply. In a perfect drinking window right now. Decanted for an hour and it was singing. Wonderful interplay of black, blue, and purple berry fruits, tar, camphor, black slate, and…

Reviewed 8 October 2016
2010

Carlisle Syrah Sonoma County

California · Sonoma County

Same as previous notes. Some ok plum and blackberry notes. Nothing much beyond that. Last bottle.

Reviewed 5 October 2016
2012

Carlisle Petite Sirah Palisades Vineyard

California · Napa Valley

PnP with extraordinarily tight and tart high-toned red and purple berry notes. NUTTY08 noted a prominent pomegranate flavor, which was dead on. Not astringent or biting, but clenched so tight I could…

Reviewed 26 August 2016
2012

Carlisle Syrah Papa's Block

Sonoma County · Russian River Valley

Same as my notes from February 2016. 93+. A decent drink now with a short decant or hold for another year.

Reviewed 9 August 2016
2013

Carlisle Syrah Sonoma County

California · Sonoma County

PnP with classic notes of dark berry fruit, berry liqueur, red and black cherry, and hints of white pepper, sanguine, and spice.

Reviewed 20 July 2016
2010

Carlisle Syrah Sonoma County

California · Sonoma County

Same notes as 12/25/2015. 88-89 points. Served alongside a 2010 Saxum Booker and 2010 Tor Reserve ROCK Syrah. The Saxum blew the others out of the water for me. Not decanted. Didn't need it. Flat and…

Reviewed 25 June 2016
2010

Carlisle Syrah Papa's Block

Sonoma County · Russian River Valley

Same as my specific notes from 8/19/2015. My last bottle. Ended up being a good Syrah with a very good QPR. Nothing earth-shattering, but a pleasant drink nonetheless. Papa's Block is consistently…

Reviewed 26 May 2016