Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

26 notes

2008

Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon Hillside Select

Napa Valley · Stags Leap District

A solid performance with this particular bottle. Decanted for a few hours, which really allowed the firm tannins to soften and the black fruit and obsidian notes to emerge. No green peppercorn or…

Reviewed 5 July 2026
1986

Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon Hillside Select

Napa Valley · Stags Leap District

Gently decanted for an hour in a small vessel. Plum, deep and dark red and black muddled cherry, leather, old cigar, torched orange rind, soil, and black currant.

Reviewed 5 January 2025
2016

Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon Hillside Select

Napa Valley · Stags Leap District

Honed, focused, chiseled, mineral, black goth berry-rock, and a mean streak all up and down it, the 2016 HSS is serious business in the best of ways. Give it another 5+ years and be rewarded. It…

Reviewed 25 May 2024
2016

Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon Hillside Select

Napa Valley · Stags Leap District

Tannic and drying, the chest on this thing is bumping and thumping with push, thrust, grip and clutch, but the fruit has a difficult time elbowing past the bro-code bullishness of the frame. Black…

Reviewed 6 June 2023
2010

Shafer Relentless

California · Napa Valley

2010 and 2015 Shafer Relentless served side-by-side.

Reviewed 5 August 2018
2015

Shafer Relentless

California · Napa Valley

2010 and 2015 Shafer Relentless served side-by-side.

Reviewed 5 August 2018
1997

Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon Hillside Select

Napa Valley · Stags Leap District

PnP and this at-first-look beauty caressed the palate with lovely black core fruit and black/blue river rock. With every moment of air, however, this HSS started to quickly soften. In little time,…

Reviewed 4 August 2018
2012

Shafer Firebreak Dessert Wine

Napa Valley · Stags Leap District

Nope. I don't get this thing at all. Serves no purpose. A syrupy simpleton. One wonky note of chocolate-blackberry goofiness. This is why most wineries shouldn't have a desert wine. 79? points.

Reviewed 7 February 2018
2013

Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon Hillside Select

Napa Valley · Stags Leap District

Classic meets modern. Tight and coiled-up, like a snake ready to strike. Pretty massive overall, but also displaying an intriguing sophistication that draws one back for another sip. Needs air! Lots…

Reviewed 7 February 2018
2014

Shafer Relentless

California · Napa Valley

Wild blackberry, plum, asphalt, wood, charcuterie, and some garrigue. Some quasi-interesting flavors trying to self-identify, but overall lacking much-needed complexity and finesse. Powerful and…

Reviewed 7 February 2018
2014

Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon One Point Five

Napa Valley · Stags Leap District

The first pour of this wine was flawed, but the staff was nice enough to serve a freshly popped bottle for comparison. The new bottle was not flawed, but it was pretty disjointed and lacking any sort…

Reviewed 7 February 2018
2014

Shafer Cabernet Sauvignon One Point Five

Napa Valley · Stags Leap District

Flawed. Slight vinegar and prune on the nose; some stemmy cedar and old world barnyard Syrah funk on the palate. Flat and tasteless otherwise.

Reviewed 7 February 2018
2015

Shafer TD-9

California · Napa Valley

Pedestrian notes of red and black currant, black cherry, dust, and wood. Linear, thin, and lacking complexity.

Reviewed 7 February 2018
2015

Shafer Chardonnay Red Shoulder Ranch

Napa / Sonoma · Carneros

Notes of green apple, Asian pear, lemon verbena, tropical fruit, acacia, and some sea salt. The initial attack started out smooth and enveloping (characteristically as most rounded-out Nor-Cal…

Reviewed 7 February 2018
2010

Shafer Relentless

California · Napa Valley

Same as all of my previous notes. Always a solid performer. A bit of air coaxed out some really nice bitter chocolate, tar, railroad tie, and black pebbly flavors to accompany the core black fruit.

Reviewed 13 January 2018
2010

Shafer Relentless

California · Napa Valley

Same as before. A solid red over the course of two days. A little tight on PnP and in need of some air throughout consumption. Ultimately, I'd recommend a short decant (2+ hours) or hold for another…

Reviewed 29 November 2017
2010

Shafer Relentless

California · Napa Valley

Same as all of my previous notes on this wine. PnP was the way to go. Performed optimally at 54 degrees throughout service. Solid 95 points during this time period. (1-1.5 hours).

Reviewed 14 July 2017
2010

Shafer Relentless

California · Napa Valley

Same as all of my other notes on this wine. Decanted for a couple of hours just for the hell of it, but it really didn't even need it. Taking a step back, this really is a gorgeous bottle of wine.…

Reviewed 9 March 2017
2010

Shafer Relentless

California · Napa Valley

Previous notes on specific flavors still apply. Awesome wine, and inching its way up in score for me as time goes on. PnP was near-perfect and ready right out of the gate.

Reviewed 25 October 2016
2010

Shafer Relentless

California · Napa Valley

Same as my previous notes on this wine. Nice dark fruits and some notable minerality. Drinking well with an hour or two decant, or hold until early 2017 for even more optimum drinking.

Reviewed 4 August 2016
2009

Shafer Relentless

California · Napa Valley

As with other CT notes, I really did like this wine quite a bit. It was impeccably balanced and still had a beautifully rich and unctuous texture and mouthfeel about it, the likes of which I don't…

Reviewed 19 April 2016
2010

Shafer Relentless

California · Napa Valley

Same as my CT notes from 09/07/2015. Great stuff. Improved with two hours in the decanter. Could probably use another year in bottle for total optimum drinking.

Reviewed 10 March 2016