Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

5,921 notes

2016

Château Fonplégade

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

A year and a half ago since my last bottle. Progressing quicker than I would have expected. I know others have speculated this will be even better with more time in the cellar. I'm on the opposite…

Reviewed 21 January 2021
2014

Vice Versa Cabernet Sauvignon Beckstoffer Las Piedras Vineyard

Napa Valley · St. Helena

It's been over three years since I've had the opportunity to take a shot at this wine. Homemade pizza on a Tuesday night? What better excuse to dip into the Vice Versa stash and see what's been…

Reviewed 20 January 2021
2017

Henri Germain et Fils Bourgogne Côte d'Or Blanc

Burgundy · Bourgogne Côte d'Or

As WOODIEBAYAREA has noted, this is very good for its level. Much better than a 16 Germain Charmes 1er I had the other night. This base Bourgogne has notable freshness and liveliness illustrative of…

Reviewed 19 January 2021
2016

Henri Germain et Fils Meursault 1er Cru Charmes

Côte de Beaune · Meursault 1er Cru

Last of three bottles. First two bottles were wet-newspaper-destroyed. This bottle was at least sound. Fairly pedestrian and, though agreeable and tasty, lacking some of the complexity and oomph I…

Reviewed 17 January 2021
2015

Fontodi Flaccianello della Pieve Colli della Toscana Centrale IGT

Tuscany · Colli della Toscana Centrale IGT

Even more filled-out than my previous bottle last year, the 2015 was rocking-out all sorts of dark berry and dusty spice goodness. A double decant with a double filtering of sediment (to which there…

Reviewed 15 January 2021
2011

Jerome Blin Champagne Les Caillasses Brut Millésime

France · Champagne

Similar to the 2008 in style and delivery, with an affable execution with medium richness and a fuller-friendly mouthfeel. The 2011 has the slight edge over the 2008 in that the 2011 has a little…

Reviewed 13 January 2021
2017

Domaine de Fondrèche Ventoux il était une fois

Southern Rhône · Ventoux

Dark mixed berries, a little funk and saline, and hints of dried herbs. Relatively smooth given its youth, but not especially expressive or interesting. Finishes a little flat in its current state.…

Reviewed 13 January 2021
2017

Jean-Jacques Confuron Bourgogne Cuvée Jeunesse

Burgundy · Bourgogne

Strawberry, rhubarb, red raspberry, soil, pine resin, and a little hint of funk. Light on its feet and stylistically a cross between old and new worlds; certainly a more lithe and airy delivery…

Reviewed 11 January 2021
2017

Domaine François Mikulski Meursault 1er Cru Les Poruzots

Côte de Beaune · Meursault 1er Cru

Even more expressive than last year. Lemon/lime zest and quince flavors intermingle well with the wet white travertine scaffolding. Punchy without being pithy. Excellent acidity and drive, all the…

Reviewed 10 January 2021
2014

Pierre Gerbais Champagne L'Originale

France · Champagne

Notes from 04/18/2020 and 11/24/2019 - Duplicates posted in the NV section, though these bottles clearly show vintage specific - hence, why I'm posting these notes here in the "2014 Pierre Gerbais…

Reviewed 10 January 2021
2018

Jean-Paul & Benoit Droin Chablis Grand Cru Vaudésir

Chablis · Grand Cru

Less of the ripe peach and cantaloupe elements on the front end with this particular bottle, instead focusing on fresh and luscious lemon and yellow pear elements that make for an invitingly…

Reviewed 9 January 2021
2016

Nicolas Maillart Champagne Grand Cru Jolivettes

Champagne · Grand Cru

Pouring a translucent light salmon color (akin to a light colored Rosé), Maillart's 2016 Jolivettes quickly goes from spritely and radiant on the initial attack to a deeper-pitched down shift at the…

Reviewed 8 January 2021
2016

Nicolas Maillart Champagne Premier Cru Mont Martin

Champagne · Premier Cru

From premier cru vines planted in 1972, the Nicolas Maillart 2016 Mont Martin is an extraordinary 100% Pinot Meunier Extra Brut that immediately impresses for its classy and harmonious flavor-display…

Reviewed 7 January 2021
2015

Christopher Tynan Wines Syrah Judge Family Vineyard

Sonoma County · Bennett Valley

Similar to last year. Even more integrated and seamless, with a finesse not often found in a domestic Syrah. The saline, olive brine, and iron notes do well to elevate the earthy dark blackberry and…

Reviewed 5 January 2021
2017

Domaine Launay-Horiot Pommard 1er Cru Les Chaponnières

Côte de Beaune · Pommard 1er Cru

Nowhere near as accessible as the awesome 2016 Chaponnieres. This 2017 is ultra-linear and lithe right now. Barely showing some dark berry and spice notes. Next-to-no depth currently. Simple and…

Reviewed 3 January 2021
2016

Domaine Henri Boillot Volnay 1er Cru Les Fremiets

Côte de Beaune · Volnay 1er Cru

I could not keep myself from tapping into another one of these bottles. Similar showing as in May 2020. Perfectly balanced and just the right amount of sappy and spice to make for a beautiful earthy…

Reviewed 3 January 2021
2017

Morlet Family Vineyards La Proportion Dorée

Sonoma County · Sonoma Coast

Yellow and white peach, lemon curd, dried apricot, honey, chamomile, plantain chip, and orange rind make for more of a white Rhône profile here than a white Bordeaux. A more serious wine, with…

Reviewed 2 January 2021
2019

Domaine Pinson Frères Chablis

Burgundy · Chablis

Simple yellow citrus and chalk notes. Medium and linear in intensity and execution. Expansion of flavor was minimal. Finish falls off fairly quickly.

Reviewed 1 January 2021
NV

Jerome Blin Champagne Cuvée Octave Zero Dosage

France · Champagne

I had to open another bottle of this since the epic fail the previous evening where its busted sibling was all about dog-in-the-rain and floppy-cardboard-in-a kiddy-pool flavors.

Reviewed 31 December 2020
2018

Simon Colin Chassagne-Montrachet 1er Cru Les Vergers

Côte de Beaune · Chassagne-Montrachet 1er Cru

Very similar to Colin's other 1er crus, the Vergers is a clean, pure, and fresh example, with a classy display of yellow citrus flavor that is notably controlled and focused. A little direct and…

Reviewed 30 December 2020