Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

3,775 notes

2014

Château Boswell Pinot Noir Absolutely Eloise Sonoma Coast

Sonoma County · Sonoma Coast

Decanted for approximately 2+ hours. Vibrant and flavorful, if just a little one-note, full of high-toned red berry fruits; strawberry, raspberry tart, and a bit of alcohol. Went down very smoothly,…

Reviewed 31 December 2015
2010

Forman Cabernet Sauvignon

California · Napa Valley

Same as my CT notes last week. Slow O2 for a little over an hour and drinking nicely. A subtle, more old-world style Cabernet.

Reviewed 31 December 2015
2012

Mending Wall Cabernet Sauvignon

California · Napa Valley

Similar to my previous CT notes on this wine, except that it really took quite a while before it opened up into anything worth gaining any interest. On initial PnP, it came across flat and muted,…

Reviewed 28 December 2015
2012

Buccella Merlot

California · Napa Valley

Brought over by a friend and decanted over the course of two hours. One of the best domestic Merlots I've ever had (and I typically do not care for most stand-alone Merlots). Beautiful, deep texture…

Reviewed 27 December 2015
2012

Sarocka Cabernet Sauvignon

Napa Valley · Spring Mountain District

Specific tasting notes were the same as my previous CT notes on this wine last week. Filled out even more magnificantly with some time in the decanter. After about two hours, it was singing with…

Reviewed 26 December 2015
2012

Eric Kent Wine Cellars Pinot Noir Sascha Marie

Sonoma County · Russian River Valley

Drank alongside a 2012 Kosta Browne RRV Pinot, the EK Sascha Marie was much better, with a vibrancy and energy that helped to elevate the red berry flavors. Similar to my CT notes from 8/10/15 on…

Reviewed 25 December 2015
2012

Kosta Browne Pinot Noir Russian River Valley

Sonoma County · Russian River Valley

Essentially the same as my previous CT notes on this wine from 11/21/15, except that some time in the decanter allowed for a little more fruit to emerge. However, this wine still came off as flat and…

Reviewed 25 December 2015
2010

Carlisle Syrah Sonoma County

California · Sonoma County

PnP with tight, cool notes of purple and black berry fruits, with additional flavors of black licorice and slate. Fairly monolithic, with only the QPR really making up for it. As a stand-alone wine,…

Reviewed 25 December 2015
2012

Sarocka Antra

Napa Valley · Spring Mountain District

PnP was initially similar to my notes last week on this wine. I then allowed it to breathe at cellar temperature for an hour in a wide-bottomed decanter. This certainly brought out more of a deeper…

Reviewed 24 December 2015
2011

Kosta Browne Pinot Noir Gap's Crown Vineyard

Sonoma County · Sonoma Coast

The only 2011 Kosta Browne in the whole lineup that survived to become a worthy Pinot from the 2011 vintage, the Gap's Crown displayed up-front flavors of black cherry, pomegranate, strawberry,…

Reviewed 23 December 2015
2012

L'Aventure Optimus

Central Coast · Paso Robles

As others have mentioned, the Optimus is clearly not in the same league as the Estate Cuvée, but at only $45, the Optimus delivers way above its price point. What a great QPR!

Reviewed 20 December 2015
2012

Altamura Cabernet Sauvignon

California · Napa Valley

Consumed with friends (otherwise I had planned on waiting until later in 2016 before reassessing this wine). Definitely glad I opened this bottle, as it has improved quite a bit. Similar to my prior…

Reviewed 20 December 2015
2008

Rudd Oakville Estate Proprietary Red

Napa Valley · Oakville

Similar to my prior CT note (but obviously I couldn't wait until 2017 as I had previously recommended). This time around, I gave the 2008 Rudd an extra point (from 95 to 96), as it certainly…

Reviewed 19 December 2015
2013

Venge Vineyards Scout's Honor

California · Napa Valley

With all due respect to Venge's homage to his dog "Scout," this wine was unfortunately disjointed and confusing. Flabby plum flavors dominate, with additional notes of muddled raspberry and…

Reviewed 19 December 2015
2012

Sarocka Antra

Napa Valley · Spring Mountain District

Tasted alongside the 2012 Sarocka Estate and the 2010 Scully Cabernets.

Reviewed 18 December 2015
2013

Venge Vineyards Merlot

Napa Valley · Oakville

A pleasantly surprising example of a Napa Merlot. Notes of plump blackberry, raspberry, plum, chocolate, and baking spices. Beautifully crafted with more complexity than I often find in this varietal.

Reviewed 18 December 2015
2013

Venge Vineyards Syrah Block I-4 Stagecoach Vineyard

California · Napa Valley

As noted by the Millennials, this Syrah starts off with a push that coaxes you into thinking it is going to go the distance, but then falls off almost immediately mid-palate. Initial notes of purple…

Reviewed 18 December 2015
2013

Venge Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Bone Ash Vineyard

Napa Valley · Calistoga

A lot going on here, with in-your-face flavors of black and blue berries, black raspberry, blackberry, black licorice, dark cacao, white chocolate, chocolate covered blueberry, cassis, asphalt/tar,…

Reviewed 18 December 2015
2012

Sarocka Cabernet Sauvignon

Napa Valley · Spring Mountain District

Tasted alongside the 2012 Antra and the 2010 Scully.

Reviewed 18 December 2015
2009

Donelan Syrah Walker Vine Hill

Sonoma County · Russian River Valley

Nearly identical to the 2008 WVH. A meaty and saline-driven syrah, with notes of stewed plum, salami, bologna, red currant, spice, sea salt, and bouquet garni. Some tannic clamp on the initial PnP,…

Reviewed 17 December 2015
2010

Carlisle Petite Sirah Palisades Vineyard

California · Napa Valley

An absolutely phenomenal example of Mike Officer's ability to extract the very best PS juice from the coveted Palisades site. Deep, inky black and purple fruits, with specific notes of ripe…

Reviewed 16 December 2015
2010

Forman Cabernet Sauvignon

California · Napa Valley

Similar to my CT notes 5 months ago. PnP with a chalky bite surrounding the red plum and black raspberry notes. 45 minutes in the decanter shed this wine of the chalky clamp on the finish, leaving…

Reviewed 15 December 2015