Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

3,775 notes

2019

001 Vintners Cabernet Sauvignon Ecotone Vineyard

California · Napa Valley

A new project by Jack Bittner, with Graeme Macdonald as winemaker, the 2019 001 (double-O[oh]-one) will be the inaugural wine from prime plots on the Ecotone site. Jack was gracious enough to meet us…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2017

Soldera (Az. Agr. Case Basse) Sangiovese Toscana IGT

Tuscany · Toscana IGT

I first tried this wine six months ago under less-than-ideal conditions. It was fantastic then, and fooled me first into thinking it was some top notch Burgundy rather than a classy Sangio (Ya, I…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2016

Promontory

California · Napa Valley

A perfect wine. And in 10 years it'll be a perfect wine. And in 15 years it'll be a perfect wine. And in 20 years it'll..well, you get the picture. So, we all know that taro card reading wine is an…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2020

Keplinger Syrah Gratus Amico Melville Vineyard

Central Coast · Santa Ynez Valley

The Donna's is much more of a Funky Cold Medina compared to its fraternal twin Block 45 sibling. Less floral as well, the Donna's smells more like a 2011 Napa Cabernet (or maybe a 2011 Cornas) than a…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2014

Tusk Estates Cabernet Sauvignon

California · Napa Valley

Huh. This was. initially pretty perplexing. Round and uber-plush. Displayed pretty yummy black and blue fruit that was indeed tasty, but lacked the extra frame and tension to keep things moving and…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2016

Adamvs Cabernet Sauvignon Estate

Napa Valley · Howell Mountain

Another bottle of this got thrown into the mix courtesy of Cristal2000. This bottle OWNED the table in its own right. A Howell Mountain beauty that really outshined its other Adamvs peers all the way…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2010

Promontory

California · Napa Valley

There is a simmering herbaceous energy that swarms around the black currant and unripe black cherry flavors, with menthol and forest floor rounding out the profile. The cooler vintage makes for a…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2020

Keplinger Syrah Gratus Amico Bien Nacido

Central Coast · Santa Maria Valley

100% Syrah from Block 45 of the Bien Nacido vineyard, the Gratus Amico leads with a bouquet of roses and a red berry fruit basket, followed by red raspberry, red and black cherry, and faint stone…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2019

Château Trotanoy

Libournais · Pomerol

I had been playing the Coravin game with this wine for a few months before finally opening the bottle tonight. It was a coiled-up beast with a super driven acid-tension thing going on that was ultra…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2018

Abreu Thorevilos

California · Napa Valley

How many different versions of wine perfection can one consume in one sitting?! Well, if you're gonna throw down with a 2018 Abreu Thorevilos, then the answer is +1 whatever other bottles of…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2020

Promontory

California · Napa Valley

I didn't get much of a read here. It was so linear and primary that any sort of logical assessment was lost between the pucker and the frame. Sour cherry and sour cherry and sour cherry. The finish…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2021

Bella Oaks Vineyard Proprietary Red

Napa Valley · Rutherford

Quick math question for you. What's 2018+2019? If you answered 4037, then you should definitely think about taking another stab at community college and reapplying for that cashier position at…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2020

MacDonald Cabernet Sauvignon

Napa Valley · Oakville

(If you want the punchline, skip all the drivel and just go to the last sentence at the bottom of this lingual mess I've created here).

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2019

Vice Versa Cabernet Sauvignon Mysterons

California · Napa Valley

The 2019 Mysterons (Ecotone) was served side-by-side with the 2018 Abreu Thorevilos. The vintages and stylistic differences between producers/winemakers was evident, with more…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2012

Promontory Penultimate

California · Napa Valley

I get that the idea is to drink this on the more 'now' side of things while your precious big daddy Promontory are resting peacefully in some dark corner of the world somewhere, but right out the…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2017

Bella Oaks Vineyard Proprietary Red

Napa Valley · Rutherford

I don't want to fall in love with 2017s. I don't even want to fall in like with 2017. In fact, I want to love 2017s as much as I love 2020s, or even 2011s for that matter. If I have to hear one more…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2012

Araujo Estate Cabernet Sauvignon Eisele Vineyard

California · Napa Valley

As before, I found this bottle compelling. I will say that it takes some time to come around, and with a fair amount of decant-type coaxing and swirling in the glass acrobatics, it starts to really…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2019

Vice Versa Cabernet Sauvignon The Magnificent Seven

California · Napa Valley

What can you say? It's M7. I've consistently given it 99 points the last few times I've had it. Why stop there? 99 it is. Always a bottle of crazy juice. If you haven't had a enough superlatives from…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2019

La Pelle Cabernet Sauvignon Reserve

California · Napa Valley

Surely the best of the bunch in terms of concentration and depth, the Reserve Cabernet offers that extra layer of density and breadth befitting a reserve designation. Powerful blackberry, black…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2014

Château Fonplégade Fleur de Fonplégade

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

Poured alongside the Adamvs wines just for a fun comparison. The Fonplégade is of course a bit of a different animal, both in terroir and price point (most vintages of Fonplégade can be had for…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2019

Colgin Cabernet Sauvignon Tychson Hill Vineyard

California · Napa Valley

Ok, so it has now gotten to the point where it infuriates me every time I have a Colgin. I mean, does every bottle always have to stomp on everything else around it due to its supreme awesomeness?!…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2021

Vice Versa Cabernet Sauvignon Beckstoffer To Kalon Vineyard

Napa Valley · Oakville

As much as the LPV and Crane are like eating a blackberry pie with the best fruit ever made on earth, the BTK is undeniably the leader of the SVD triad. The concentration is so insanely on-point,…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2019

La Pelle Cabernet Sauvignon Alluvium

Napa Valley · St. Helena

The powerhouse of the three SVDs, the Alluvium elbows past the partygoers and shows its upfront opulence and swanky luxury. Ripe blackberry is encircled with a bit of booze on the initial cascade of…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2018

Adamvs Cabernet Sauvignon Estate

Napa Valley · Howell Mountain

After having the earth-shattering 2016 Adamvs, it is admittedly a tad more difficult to "academically" assess its 2018 sibling. Ironically, I catch a little old school profile here, with grandpa's…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2021

Vice Versa Cabernet Sauvignon Beckstoffer Dr. Crane Vineyard

Napa Valley · St. Helena

The 2021 LPV and Crane especially lead with vanilla and chocolate notes, flaunting their baby fat like the happiest kid on the planet with a triple scoop ice cream cone in one hand and a pinwheel in…

Reviewed 7 April 2023