Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

794 notes

2019

David Leclapart Champagne Premier Cru Cuvée L'Aphrodisiaque

Champagne · Premier Cru

This has done well to resolve some of its angularity and brashness over the last year since my last bottle. Signature Leclapart barrel spice is complimented by energetic flavors of pear, lemon,…

Reviewed 7 March 2026
2013

Dom Pérignon Champagne

France · Champagne

As before, green and yellow pear, yeast, lemon and lime juice and pith, limestone, and white and green melon notes dominate. Finishes flinty and yeasty, with the compelling green notes repeating (not…

Reviewed 7 March 2026
NV

Jacques Selosse Initial

Champagne · Grand Cru

Served side by side with another Initial disgorged in 2024 (2018 base), this 2016 disgorgement (2010 base) shows more mature orange, golden raisin, and honey notes, with a slight downshift in energy…

Reviewed 7 March 2026
NV

Jacques Selosse Initial

Champagne · Grand Cru

This bottle once again affirms my affection for more recently disgorged versions of this wine. Served side by side with another Initial disgorged in 2016 (2010 base), this 2024 disgorgement (2018…

Reviewed 7 March 2026
2016

Chartogne-Taillet Champagne Hors Serie

France · Champagne

As before, pear, cardamom, ginger, lemon, limestone, and olive oil notes all make for a compelling experience. The perfect amount of acid and cut to counterbalance the enveloping volume saturating…

Reviewed 7 March 2026
2018

Chartogne-Taillet Champagne Blanc de Blancs Heurtebise

France · Champagne

This particular bottle was really torqued up and super linear on the first pass. More chalky and white fruited, with a chiseled profile that was night and day compared to the much more giving 2016…

Reviewed 7 March 2026
2014

Bérêche et Fils Champagne Premier Cru Le Cran

Champagne · Premier Cru

There is a compounding richness here that balances volume with lift and freshness, maintaining a steady equilibrium that provides perfect weight with drive. The hallmark chestnut and peach notes are…

Reviewed 14 February 2026
2018

Chartogne-Taillet Champagne Blanc de Blancs Heurtebise

France · Champagne

A fantastic showing, and the best yet from this bottling, the Heurtebise displays wonderful pear, ripe lemon, and melon fruit flavors that are perfectly carried on a limestone and chalk carriage.…

Reviewed 2 February 2026
2013

Bérêche et Fils Champagne Premier Cru Le Cran

Champagne · Premier Cru

Baked apples and spices lead the charge, with honey, limestone, grilled lemon, ginger, quince, and Rainier cherry filling in the profile. In a lovely spot now, with solid freshness and focus. Never…

Reviewed 1 February 2026
2018

Huré Frères Champagne L'Instantanée Blanc de Noirs

France · Champagne

Cherry, limestone, bruised lemon, and white raspberry. A fairly simple attack, with limited expansion and a constricted mid-palate that prevents the fruit from offering much added depth at the…

Reviewed 31 January 2026
2007

Bollinger Champagne R.D. Extra Brut

France · Champagne

Ginger root, poached pear, apple pie crust, pecan, honey, and granite make for a gourmand experience, but one with sound cut and lift. The attack isn't sweet, which adds to the experience of focus…

Reviewed 31 January 2026
2012

Huré Frères Champagne Terre Natale

France · Champagne

Yellow apple, yellow citrus, and yellow pear fruit dominate, with hints of oxidized and baked notes. Rounded and a bit one-note, this hits with "yellow fruit" (slightly poached) plopping on the…

Reviewed 20 January 2026
2006

Philipponnat Champagne Les Cintres

France · Champagne

Similar in profile to the 2008 Cintres, this 2006 is an absolute stunner of a wine. Perfectly cadenced flavors of ripe red and yellow apple, ginger, honey, poached pear, limestone, olive oil, grilled…

Reviewed 19 January 2026
2019

Laherte Frères Champagne Extra Brut Les Vignes d'Autrefois

France · Champagne

Salt rock, cherry water, unripe quince, granite, crunchy yellow and red pear, bruised lemon, chalk, and brioche. Zippy and a little high strung at first, deepening with time in the glass. More yellow…

Reviewed 17 January 2026
2020

Chartogne-Taillet Champagne Les Barres

France · Champagne

Firm and precise on entry, this bottle is another strong showing. As before, ginger, Mirabelle plum, brown, red, and yellow pear, honey, wood, and granite lead the charge, followed by a salty bite…

Reviewed 4 January 2026
2018

Doyard Champagne Premier Cru Extra Brut Clos de l'Abbaye

Champagne · Premier Cru

Much improved from last year's stricter and more linear performance, this bottle was undulating all sorts of honeydew melon, mint, lemon, travertine, and white/yellow pear flavors. Still a tad…

Reviewed 4 January 2026