Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

592 notes

1982

Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande

Médoc · Pauillac

After a strong showing from a 1996 I had a bit ago, I was hoping this 1982 might offer up a similar profile with just a little more age on it to showcase tempting tertiary notes and classical Lalande…

Reviewed 12 June 2025
1997

Château Cheval Blanc

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

Funky, tired, and fairly flat. There were grumblings about possible questionable storage here, which I unfortunately think to be the case. Cheval is one of my favorite Right Bank houses, but I think…

Reviewed 12 June 2025
2018

Promontory Penultimate

California · Napa Valley

My notes read, "Muted and COOLER in profile; linear but still approachable. A serious side with an affable one too. Blacker style; currant and black cherry." Missing the extra layer of the flagship…

Reviewed 2 May 2025
2005

Château Larcis Ducasse

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

A better showing than a few months ago, this bottle was fresher and more focused. It still seems to be straining for a full depth of flavor, so perhaps more time in bottle is needed. It's very lifted…

Reviewed 2 May 2025
1995

Château Cos d'Estournel

Médoc · Saint-Estèphe

Instantly captivating, with beautiful tobacco, leather, macerated plum, and orange rind flavors that roll across the palate with classicism and sophistication. Super fresh and fully mature, with no…

Reviewed 2 May 2025
2019

Bella Oaks Vineyard Proprietary Red

Napa Valley · Rutherford

This sample was a Chewy McChewster, with black currant, dark soil-driven black fruit, licorice, and super dark spices all bundled into a chocolate chunk holiday package. I wanted to pour this thing…

Reviewed 1 May 2025
2020

Screaming Eagle The Flight

California · Napa Valley

Dark without being deep, the superficial expression of flavor here struggles to find foundation and direction. The elements are searching for each other, but the overall execution appears misguided…

Reviewed 1 May 2025
2019

Sloan

Napa Valley · Rutherford

Black fruit and cedar, with some mulchy elements that give it both earthy and modern vibes. Finishes a touch light, especially compared to other producers in 2019. Stylistically it's a little hard to…

Reviewed 1 May 2025
2019

Sloan Asterisk

California · Napa Valley

Red and black cherry flavors present as a medium expression, with some dark fruit and cedar notes adding to the profile. A fairly simple delivery overall, especially for the 2019 vintage.

Reviewed 1 May 2025
2022

Bella Oaks Vineyard Proprietary Red

Napa Valley · Rutherford

This latest iteration of Bella Oaks starts out as a round and fruity magoo, but it turns a little more serious as it swirls in the glass. Enter a nicely placed grip midway through the execution, with…

Reviewed 30 April 2025
2021

BOND Vecina

California · Napa Valley

Linear and strict, with an old school vibe that represents as one of the more rustic versions of VHR. This is not atypical of Bond of course, as consumers of this producer, and in particular the…

Reviewed 30 April 2025
2018

Futo 5500

Napa Valley · Stags Leap District

Black fruit and cedar, with some redder cherry and soil notes to add contrast and interest. Excellent lift and freshness, with a smidge less depth than the 2018 Oakville served next to it. Drinking…

Reviewed 30 April 2025
2018

Futo Oakville

Napa Valley · Oakville

No denying the quality of Futo's Oakville Cabernet, with its seductive dark fruit and chewy (but ethereal) mouthfeel, this is a textural delight no matter how you slice it. Black cherry and currant…

Reviewed 30 April 2025
2015

Bryant Family Vineyard Bettina

California · Napa Valley

Still showing beautifully since last having this three years ago, the 2015 Bettina is a classy wine. It still carries those chocolate and soil notes that compliment the dark (slightly rich) fruit.…

Reviewed 30 April 2025
2020

Château L'Evangile

Libournais · Pomerol

2020 Lafleur (99+) 2020 Cheval Blanc (97+) 2020 Ausone (99-100) 2020 Trotanoy (97) 2020 L'Evangile (96-97)

Reviewed 14 March 2025
2020

Château Ausone

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

2020 Lafleur (99+) 2020 Cheval Blanc (97+) 2020 Ausone (99-100) 2020 Trotanoy (97) 2020 L'Evangile (96-97)

Reviewed 12 March 2025
2020

Château Cheval Blanc

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

2020 Lafleur (99+) 2020 Cheval Blanc (97+) 2020 Ausone (99-100) 2020 Trotanoy (97) 2020 L'Evangile (96-97)

Reviewed 12 March 2025
2020

Château Lafleur

Libournais · Pomerol

2020 Lafleur (99+) 2020 Cheval Blanc (97+) 2020 Ausone (99-100) 2020 Trotanoy (97) 2020 L'Evangile (96-97)

Reviewed 12 March 2025
2020

Château Trotanoy

Libournais · Pomerol

2020 Lafleur (99+) 2020 Cheval Blanc (97+) 2020 Ausone (99-100) 2020 Trotanoy (97) 2020 L'Evangile (96-97)

Reviewed 12 March 2025
2005

Château Larcis Ducasse

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

Freshness is at the forefront with the 20% Cab Franc pushing the Merlot to the side and flooding the senses with red/purple licorice, red cherry, and floral notes on the playful attack. With more…

Reviewed 11 February 2025
2015

Château Belair-Monange

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

This fell flat with a 4-5oz Coravin pull. It was next to a 2015 Rauzan-Segla that initially was just as dumb, but managed to wake up and eventually obliterate the Belair-Monange. The B-M displayed…

Reviewed 4 September 2024
2015

Château Rauzan-Ségla

Médoc · Margaux

It's been five years since last having this wine. I pulled a Coravin glass of this a few months ago and thought it was one of the most boring wines I'd ever tried in my life. Red currant, red cherry,…

Reviewed 4 September 2024
2015

Scarecrow Monsieur Étain

Napa Valley · Rutherford

It's no Scarecrow, but the M. Etain isn't necessarily trying to be. Next to its big brother, it's honestly barely worth talking about. But if you can peel yourself away from the notion that it will…

Reviewed 29 July 2024
2013

Opus One

California · Napa Valley

The nose here is feral and a little funky, but there is a nice injection of red/black fruit, Christmas spice, black cherry, and black currant. The finish is notably long, with the back end texture…

Reviewed 29 July 2024