Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

592 notes

2017

Opus One

California · Napa Valley

Fruity on the nose; fruity on palate. Red berry (cranberry) dominates, with candied red cherry, cassis, and red currant. The profile is. red. With air, it becomes more linear and superficial. The…

Reviewed 29 July 2024
2019

Opus One

California · Napa Valley

Oh bejeezus, this is one seriously stern arm-crossed child who doesn't know how to use its big words when it's cranky. Not much on nose; not much on the palate. Linear and flat-lined, with barely any…

Reviewed 29 July 2024
NV

Opus One Overture

California · Napa Valley

A product of the 18/19 vintage, which as a blend should be pretty ideal given the successes of those two vintages. Super fruity on nose, with a predominantly black fruited profile overall. On the…

Reviewed 29 July 2024
2019

Harlan Estate

Napa Valley · Oakville

In a lineup of top shelf 2019 Napa Cabs blind, this undoubtedly showed near the top of the heap. Of course the immediate argument is that it should always be the singular one on top (short of a…

Reviewed 25 July 2024
2019

Realm Cellars The Absurd

California · Napa Valley

In a blind amongst some stellar performers (Kinsman, Macdonald, Scarecrow, Colgin), the 2019 Absurd showed as lighter bodied (I mean, for a Realm) and redder fruited than I would have anticipated. It…

Reviewed 24 July 2024
2019

Tenuta San Guido Sassicaia

Bolgheri · Sassicaia

I've had various vintages of these wines a number of times now, and this was the most unresolved I've experienced the beloved Sassicaia. Pours light and clear, posing as a baby Barolo with a broken…

Reviewed 17 June 2024
2010

Abreu Thorevilos

California · Napa Valley

Whoo doggies! Fire water. My initial notes read, "Enormous, alcoholic, black raspberry bomb with tons of booze. Finish cocktail driven. Man, the heat on repeat!" I was pretty surprised what a slap…

Reviewed 17 June 2024
1996

Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande

Médoc · Pauillac

This is what I look for in a Bordeaux with some age on it. Fresh and complete, with both solid fruit flavors and complex secondary and tertiary notes adding interest. Red/black cherry and plum…

Reviewed 13 June 2024
1986

Château Mouton Rothschild

Médoc · Pauillac

I see high praise here, and fundamentally I certainly understand it. I just didn't experience it to the full throttle degree of others. Sun drenched leather, sherry, oolong tea, burnt orange zest,…

Reviewed 10 June 2024
2010

Château Trotanoy

Libournais · Pomerol

Red fruit dominant, with smatterings of black currant, hope chest, black tea, and cedar. Though I found this to be fresh and solid, its overall flavor profile drank older than what I'd expect from…

Reviewed 10 June 2024
2006

Pride Mountain Vineyards Reserve Claret

North Coast · Napa / Sonoma

Relatively thin and diluted red currant, cedar, earth, and macerated red cherry flavors make for a seemingly tired wine that is trying to hold it all together but seems to be fraying with every…

Reviewed 25 May 2024
2019

Ovid Red Wine

California · Napa Valley

Gothic and black as the night is long, the 2019 Ovid is a White Zombie black asphalt Thunderkiss '65 blackberry bonfire of tar, embers, black soil, obsidian blood, and Kraken ink. An intense…

Reviewed 25 May 2024
2020

Château Cheval Blanc

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

A few Coravin pulls from this bottle remind me that 2020 Cheval Blanc is an off-the-charts pure and regal expression, but it will require patience for sure. This had a flash in the glass of…

Reviewed 28 April 2024
2019

Château Margaux

Médoc · Margaux

Brighter red cherry with some purple-black fruit kick off the straight-shot profile of the 2019 Margaux. To no one's surprise, this is about as primary and linear as it gets in its current state. The…

Reviewed 26 April 2024
2015

Château Latour Grand Vin

Médoc · Pauillac

Incredible polish and poise here, with a linear profile that is just starting to give in the fruit department. This presents as a fairly serious wine, and one that will need more than a handful of…

Reviewed 26 April 2024
2021

Vice Versa Beatrix Beckstoffer To Kalon Vineyard

Napa Valley · Oakville

A pretty wine, with violets and juicy red/purple fruit popping on the palate. Here the nose is muted, but the affable flavors skip along the front end upon first sip, marking the path of a wine that…

Reviewed 24 April 2024
2021

Bella Oaks Vineyard Proprietary Red

Napa Valley · Rutherford

This is as solid as it ever has been compared to the last sample I was lucky enough to try the year prior. At first, it was a gushing glow of fruit awesomeness all at once, but with some air to…

Reviewed 15 April 2024
2001

Château Cos d'Estournel

Médoc · Saint-Estèphe

This bottle was pristine, and needed at least a couple of hours of decanted air to get into form and offer some decent flavor expansion. Plum, black cherry, cedar, dusty spice, and subtle hints of…

Reviewed 21 January 2024
2018

Château Canon

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

There is a polish here that immediately adds to the textural profile of this Canon. Somewhat plush, but not so much that it makes for too fruity or flabby of a delivery, the 2018 is similar…

Reviewed 7 January 2024
2013

Futo Oakville

Napa Valley · Oakville

Ya, so, I don't want to like this wine at all, but there is no denying this is top shelf stuff right here, so much so that the only reason I'm not jumping to 100 is because I am in one of those moods…

Reviewed 17 December 2023
2006

Château Valandraud

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

The 2006 is a bit reserved, and even tired along its execution of red and some black fruit flavors, with a shorter than expected finish. A 2009 eclipsed this by a mile. The 2006's freshness was…

Reviewed 24 November 2023
2009

Château Valandraud

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

A compelling bottle of wine. In great spot, with smooth tannins but great grip, relaxing just enough to allow the dark and somewhat earthy fruit come in. This obliterated a 2006 Valandraud next to…

Reviewed 24 November 2023
2019

Château Valandraud

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

I was able to try two separate bottles side by side at the estate. The first was a fresh PnP and the other had been open in bottle for 16 hours.

Reviewed 24 November 2023
2016

Château Valandraud

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

I had much to gush about with this 2016 back when I had it in April. My notes still ring true for the most part, but this bottle was a bit more reserved. Clearly, 2016 is a solid vintage for…

Reviewed 24 November 2023
2011

Château Valandraud

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

When in St. Emilion recently, there were a lot of wineries and wine shops pushing out their 2011s, declaring that the vintage had come around and was in a great drinking window. Honestly, I always…

Reviewed 24 November 2023