Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

592 notes

2009

Château Cheval Blanc

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

Instantly captivating, and clearly the stallion of the stable, the powerful push on the front end of the 2009 Cheval Blanc benchpresses the initial thrust of dark black and red cherry, licorice,…

Reviewed 24 June 2023
2012

Château Cheval Blanc

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

Without question the best 2012 Bordeaux I've had to date, this bottling of Cheval Blanc is a smooth operator through and through. With an elegance (not fragility) that interlaces the core red cherry,…

Reviewed 24 June 2023
2020

Château Cheval Blanc

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

Well ok ya'll, I'm-a gonna hafta tell a secret here now, cuz anyone even remotely thinkin' bout bustin' out their plastic money chomper from their wallets best do so with haste, cuz I just grabbed a…

Reviewed 24 June 2023
2019

Château Cheval Blanc

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

The nose on this monster is off the hook crazy intoxicating. The attack on the palate is less mind-altering initially, with a hyper-linear and primary delivery of powerfully torqued-up unripe black…

Reviewed 6 June 2023
2010

Château Cheval Blanc

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

Dark chocolate, black cherry, stewed plum, medjool date, menthol, and anise dominate the profile, with earthy elements complementing chewy black licorice, purple flowers, cedar, and Christmas spice.…

Reviewed 6 June 2023
2018

Château Lafleur

Libournais · Pomerol

Even on the first glass from a pop-n-pour (cuz you have to get after it early on this wine, otherwise it'll be drained in the blink of an eye amongst this eager group of wine mongers), the 2018…

Reviewed 6 June 2023
2012

Château Lafleur

Libournais · Pomerol

Allow me to sum up my experience of tasting the 2004 and 2012 Lafleur in three simple words: They're not 2018.

Reviewed 6 June 2023
2004

Château Lafleur

Libournais · Pomerol

Allow me to sum up my experience of tasting the 2004 and 2012 Lafleur in three simple words: They're not 2018.

Reviewed 6 June 2023
1996

Château Margaux

Médoc · Margaux

Leather, burnt orange peel (or maybe I just think of this because this Margaux has an Old Fashion type of vibe to it), stewed Amarena cherries, forest floor, bark, and sherry. There is still some…

Reviewed 6 June 2023
1983

Château Margaux

Médoc · Margaux

The nose and the palate match, with a sherry liqueur note that stays prominent throughout the delivery. Finishes with a bite. Muddled and stewed cherries, mushroom, leather, golden raisin, and pink…

Reviewed 6 June 2023
2015

Vérité La Joie

California · Sonoma County

More accessible and blacker fruited than its 2013 sibling served next to it, the 2015 is still just as medium-bodied but offers more mouth-watering fruit, with less of the 2013's green elements…

Reviewed 6 June 2023
2013

Vérité La Joie

California · Sonoma County

Grippy blackberry, with healthy doses of green peppercorns, bark, menthol, and pyrazine elements make for a profile that is fairly strict and taut. There is a bitter tinge that carries through the…

Reviewed 6 June 2023
2001

Harlan Estate

California · Napa Valley

With dark berry, earth, and a bit of sherrying (already?) permeating the profile, the 2001 Harlan is all class. Muddled black cherry, dry cinnamon stick, leather, and menagerie of tertiary elements,…

Reviewed 6 June 2023
2010

Abreu Madrona Ranch

California · Napa Valley

On day one, this was a blacker fruit and mineral dominated beast. I was loving it, but I was even more enamored with it on the second day, where the body really filled out and notes of earth,…

Reviewed 6 June 2023
2005

Colgin IX Estate

California · Napa Valley

Initially angular (surprisingly for a Colgin) and displaying some heat and bite, luckily this IX doesn't take long before it settles into a more comfortable glide. Tertiary flavors of leather,…

Reviewed 6 June 2023
2014

Colgin Cariad

California · Napa Valley

Plum, black cherry, and the sweat of a Vegas nightclubber, the 2014 Cariad offers a little rave succulence and opulence with a little parental shoulder angel sternness. More former than the latter,…

Reviewed 6 June 2023
2015

Colgin Cariad

California · Napa Valley

Red and black fruits present as ripe and succulently semi-sweet at the onset. The first sip is kinda like gulping a bowl of the rainbow milk left in the bowl after you just wolf down a solid helping…

Reviewed 6 June 2023
2018

Harlan Estate

Napa Valley · Oakville

At first pass, this is a crunchy unripe black cherry covered in salty sawdust. I recall having that "Uh-Oh" feeling, wondering, "What wine is this? Did someone throw in a pirate here??" It doesn't…

Reviewed 2 June 2023
2016

Futo Oakville

Napa Valley · Oakville

An awesome combination of fresh and brooding. I love the interplay of flavors here, with blackberries and purple plums dancing with the black minerality and meaty saline notes. I waffled between…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

BOND St. Eden

California · Napa Valley

Deep and rich, but with a black fruited and mineral cut that starts out angular but quickly moves into a nice combination of grippy and giving. This is an interesting wine in that it starts out…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

Colgin IX Estate

California · Napa Valley

Compared to wine before it in the lineup (which was a red-"fruited" [mostly tannic] Abreu Thorevilos), this was all about black fruit, bitter chocolate, and black minerality. Did I mention black?…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

Abreu Thorevilos

California · Napa Valley

Red, powerful, tannic, and dry, with a woody finish that makes for an arid exit. A salty olive brine note adds to the initial feeling of astringency. With air, menthol, gravel, and unripe red cherry…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

Château Haut-Bailly

Graves · Pessac-Léognan

Still about 3-5 years before prime time, though there is an accessibility that displays pure and clean black and red cherry, black currant, cedar, dried roses, and hints of tobacco leaf. It rides a…

Reviewed 23 April 2023
2016

Château Valandraud

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

With a makeup of 90% Merlot, 7% Cabernet Franc, and 3% Cabernet Sauvignon (per Valandraud's spec sheets. Note, however, that I've seen other erroneous "pro" reports that list the CF as high as 15%…

Reviewed 17 April 2023
2015

Château Beau-Séjour Bécot

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

A little Merlot-y at times, with plumy, softer and rounder contours presenting like hanging out and watching tv with your best friend, or maybe just a decent friend. A chill experience without being…

Reviewed 16 April 2023