Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

5,921 notes

2023

Henri Boillot Meursault 1er Cru Gouttes d'Or

Côte de Beaune · Meursault 1er Cru

Heavy reduction and a bit of heat kick off flavors of sour lemon and lime, lemon pith, clementine, honeydew, white melon rind, and lemon verbena. After a two hour decant, this was less reduced and…

Reviewed 19 July 2025
2014

Lail Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Mole Hill

Napa Valley · Howell Mountain

Blackberry, dark wet soil, black licorice, and anise make for a heavy showing. A bit of a sandbaggy bruiser, but with overly rounded and soft contours hidden under its mass of fruit; indicative of a…

Reviewed 15 July 2025
2007

Larkmead Vineyards The Lark

California · Napa Valley

It's been eight years since I've had this wine and it appears to be showing its age in anti-Benjamin Button fashion. It feels like another flashy 2007 that is tanking faster than it should (looking…

Reviewed 15 July 2025
1998

Vérité

California · Sonoma County

More black fruited than I would have expected given its age, but the leather and soil elements waltz in and provide a layer or two of complexity that holds interest. It's a little Plain Jane in…

Reviewed 15 July 2025
1997

Heitz Cellar Cabernet Sauvignon Bella Oaks

Napa Valley · Rutherford

Plum, cherry, leather, dust, and some sherry notes. Classical in form all the way around. Past its prime in terms of freshness and tannic structure, presenting with a softness that is pleasant but…

Reviewed 15 July 2025
2019

Jean-Paul & Benoit Droin Chablis Grand Cru Grenouilles

Chablis · Grand Cru

Fresh lemon/lime juice, iodine, chlorophyll, and sea salt carry a nice punch of flavor, all wrapped around a beautiful beam of acidity. The wood treatment is deftly judicious and almost…

Reviewed 15 July 2025
2019

Domaine Nowack Champagne La Tuilerie Extra Brut

France · Champagne

Notably better than the 2018, this vintage carries an extra level of intensity and focus. Melon and pear notes dominate on first pass. With air and a few hours to open up, it evolves into a riper and…

Reviewed 14 July 2025
2018

Chartogne-Taillet Champagne Chemin de Reims

France · Champagne

Best bottle of this so far. A nice bead of minerality to counterbalance the spiced apple, lemon, limestone, olive oil, and salty yuzu flavors. After an hour or two it really opens up beautifully.

Reviewed 13 July 2025
NV

Geoffroy Champagne Premier Cru Expression Brut

Champagne · Premier Cru

From Magnum. 2017 base. Doughy and chewy on entry, with a dosage-driven attack that is rich and lactic. Some wet chalk and white/yellow stone fruit claw their ways through the bread, but this is…

Reviewed 8 July 2025
2016

DuMOL Chardonnay Chloe Ritchie Vineyard

Sonoma County · Russian River Valley

A little gummy and sluggish on entry. Margarine, lemon curd, pineapple, olive oil, and overripe yellow pear flesh. Not undrinkable, but brassy and heavy; viscous in a way that makes for a chewy…

Reviewed 6 July 2025
2013

Revana Cabernet Sauvignon

California · Napa Valley

At peak, at least in terms of its components continuing to harmonize in a synchronized outpouring of freshness, fruit flavor and expansion, and focus. It has become a bit of a one hit wonder, but the…

Reviewed 6 July 2025
2013

Sine Qua Non Syrah ♂

California · Central Coast

A very well preserved bottle here. Purple berries, blackberry, pine resin, and hints of leather. Still a decent chunk of primary fruit present, but I appreciate the restraint and control on the…

Reviewed 6 July 2025
2013

Sine Qua Non Grenache ♀

California · Central Coast

Dark and deeply pitched black raspberry and spice. Bits of leather and garrigue add interest. Still a bit of a bruiser on the initial attack, but gains some elegance on the back end. Drink now for…

Reviewed 6 July 2025
2021

Walter Scott Chardonnay Justice Vineyard

Willamette Valley · Eola - Amity Hills

Hallmark reduction that eventually gives way to lime and lemon juice zing. Not terribly complex, but surely a bright and fresh hit of citrus verve. Drink or hold.

Reviewed 6 July 2025
2019

Promontory

California · Napa Valley

2019 Napa blind of Promontory, Colgin Tychson, and Kinsman La Voleuse.

Reviewed 3 July 2025
NV

Krug Champagne Brut Grande Cuvée Edition 171eme

France · Champagne

Amalgamated power, finesse, texture, breadth, and focus all come together in an alluring package of nutty oxidative flavors intermingled with poached pear, grilled lemon, salty yuzu, limestone, and…

Reviewed 3 July 2025
2019

Chartogne-Taillet Champagne Chemin de Reims

France · Champagne

An upfront yeastier showing this go-around. Time in the glass shows more evolved white melon, yellow pear, lemon, and travertine flavors. Drink or hold, though I would recommend the latter. On day…

Reviewed 3 July 2025
NV

Jacques Selosse Initial

Champagne · Grand Cru

The best combination of unctuous/umami and vibrancy. Oxidative orangey notes combine with yellow lemon, pear, yuzu, apricot, and limestone flavors. Beautiful execution, with a full and lifted finish.

Reviewed 3 July 2025