Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

2,570 notes

2019

Opus One

California · Napa Valley

Oh bejeezus, this is one seriously stern arm-crossed child who doesn't know how to use its big words when it's cranky. Not much on nose; not much on the palate. Linear and flat-lined, with barely any…

Reviewed 29 July 2024
NV

Opus One Overture

California · Napa Valley

A product of the 18/19 vintage, which as a blend should be pretty ideal given the successes of those two vintages. Super fruity on nose, with a predominantly black fruited profile overall. On the…

Reviewed 29 July 2024
2019

Dana Estates Cabernet Sauvignon Onda

California · Napa Valley

Compared to the 2019 Vaso served in the same lineup, this Onda shows elevated concentration and precision. Some licorice emerges, along with black cherry and plum. There exists some notable…

Reviewed 29 July 2024
2019

Vaso Cabernet Sauvignon

California · Napa Valley

Plum and ripe black cherry intermingle with spice and cedar notes, making for a little bit of an old school profile here. The tannins show as slightly elevated, clipping the finish and simplifying…

Reviewed 29 July 2024
2015

Vaso Cabernet Sauvignon

California · Napa Valley

A dirt-worshipper funkafication on nose, enough that I would have thought this was a cooked Pegau CdP Reservee. On the palate, biting and nearly fruit-muted, with leather and dusty cherry flavors…

Reviewed 29 July 2024
2019

Dana Estates Cabernet Sauvignon Hershey Vineyard

Napa Valley · Howell Mountain

Chiseled and focused, with the edges slowly (and I mean slowwwwwly) kinda-rounding toward the finish. Less of a plum profile compared to the Vaso and Onda, this Dana is more about tightly wrapped…

Reviewed 29 July 2024
2020

Spottswoode Cabernet Sauvignon Lyndenhurst

Napa Valley · St. Helena

Black cherry and black raspberry lead the front end. Plum then begins to overpower the profile, becoming plummy and jammy at times. Mid-palate is medium with a round finish that quickly turns…

Reviewed 29 July 2024
2013

Opus One

California · Napa Valley

The nose here is feral and a little funky, but there is a nice injection of red/black fruit, Christmas spice, black cherry, and black currant. The finish is notably long, with the back end texture…

Reviewed 29 July 2024
2015

Scarecrow Monsieur Étain

Napa Valley · Rutherford

It's no Scarecrow, but the M. Etain isn't necessarily trying to be. Next to its big brother, it's honestly barely worth talking about. But if you can peel yourself away from the notion that it will…

Reviewed 29 July 2024
2019

Harlan Estate

Napa Valley · Oakville

In a lineup of top shelf 2019 Napa Cabs blind, this undoubtedly showed near the top of the heap. Of course the immediate argument is that it should always be the singular one on top (short of a…

Reviewed 25 July 2024
2019

Cliff Lede Cabernet Sauvignon SongBook

California · Napa Valley

In a blind of 2019 top shelf Napa Cabs, the Songbook held its own with beautiful persistence and push of flavors. The expansion of dark and almost lush fruit was immediate, with an open and giving…

Reviewed 25 July 2024
2019

Kinsman Eades Cabernet Sauvignon Anjea Sleeping Lady Vineyard

Napa Valley · Yountville

In a blind with other 2019 Napa Cabs, the Anjea performed especially well; so well in fact, that it was head-to-head with its sibling Voleuse, as well as other heavy hitters like Harlan. Macdonald,…

Reviewed 25 July 2024
2019

Spottswoode Cabernet Sauvignon Estate

Napa Valley · St. Helena

Though youthfully primary and slightly strict at this stage, the 2019 is packed with sophistication and beautiful potential. It's a serious and stern presentation currently, but it makes its mark…

Reviewed 25 July 2024
2020

Spottswoode Cabernet Sauvignon Estate

Napa Valley · St. Helena

Linear and superficial in execution, with notes of vanilla, cedar, blackberry seed, and currant which struggle to expand or gain depth. Finishes direct, bitter, lean, and without much personality.…

Reviewed 25 July 2024
2019

Scarecrow Cabernet Sauvignon

Napa Valley · Rutherford

I've had this wine a couple of times now. In a blind a few months back, it showed a little older than the other modern Napa Cabs, at least in the sense that the profile displayed some leather and…

Reviewed 24 July 2024
2019

Realm Cellars The Absurd

California · Napa Valley

In a blind amongst some stellar performers (Kinsman, Macdonald, Scarecrow, Colgin), the 2019 Absurd showed as lighter bodied (I mean, for a Realm) and redder fruited than I would have anticipated. It…

Reviewed 24 July 2024
2016

Spottswoode Cabernet Sauvignon Estate

Napa Valley · St. Helena

Cutting to the chase, this was a rocket ship on day two. Day one was reserved and a little linear, with red to black fruit dominating the profile. Finished flavorful but a bit strict on the back end.…

Reviewed 24 June 2024
2021

Memento Mori Cabernet Sauvignon Vine Hill Ranch

Napa Valley · Oakville

Balanced and smooth, especially for such a young pup. Super fruity, in fact, one of the fruitiest renditions from this site that I can remember. Notes of mixed berry basket, boysenberry, licorice,…

Reviewed 20 June 2024
2014

Vice Versa Cabernet Sauvignon The Magnificent Seven

California · Napa Valley

The 2014 M7 had been the only vintage of M7 I had not tasted until now. This particular bottle showed a relatively sweet and rich profile, with perhaps less delineation of flavor than more recent…

Reviewed 20 June 2024
2021

Scarecrow Cabernet Sauvignon

Napa Valley · Rutherford

This dude is an unresolved fruity spider monkey boinging back and forth from round and bulbous to angular and abrupt, with a simple and shorter finish that seemed even slightly watery. Like a 2010…

Reviewed 17 June 2024
2015

Colgin Cabernet Sauvignon Tychson Hill Vineyard

California · Napa Valley

Great fruit concentration, with black cherry, earth/soil, bitter chocolate chunk, and spice leading the flavor cavalry. The back end is yummy and slightly ravenous, with a filling/decently deep…

Reviewed 17 June 2024
2010

Abreu Thorevilos

California · Napa Valley

Whoo doggies! Fire water. My initial notes read, "Enormous, alcoholic, black raspberry bomb with tons of booze. Finish cocktail driven. Man, the heat on repeat!" I was pretty surprised what a slap…

Reviewed 17 June 2024