Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

27 notes

2021

Keplinger Eldorado

California · Sierra Foothills

85% Viognier/15% Chardonnay. Strong grapefruit, lemon juice, and rock notes. A vibrant and high-riding yellow citrus white, finishing with a slight pucker factor but also incredible purity. Previous…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2015

Keplinger Caldera

Sierra Foothills · El Dorado County

Iron, earth, black raspberry, muddled red raspberry, and plum notes fill the mouth with superb purity. The bit of age the Caldera has received in bottle has helped broaden the span of flavor. This is…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2015

Keplinger Sumo

Sierra Foothills · Amador County

The one thing I was curious about with this sample was the integration of the Viognier element. Past infant Sumos have been overridden by the floral component put out by the Viognier, masking what…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2012

Favia Syrah Quarzo

Sierra Foothills · Amador County

It tasted like Syrah...

Reviewed 4 January 2019
2012

Favia Syrah Quarzo

Sierra Foothills · Amador County

Previous notes apply. This bested a '13 Carlisle Sonoma Syrah served next to it, as the Favia had a greater breadth overall, especially in regards to its complexity of flavors. Medium mid-palate,…

Reviewed 14 September 2018
2012

Favia Syrah Quarzo

Sierra Foothills · Amador County

Previous notes apply, except that after a few hours of air, the Viognier component started to mellow out and seemed to work its way more seamlessly into the Syrah element. Still could use another…

Reviewed 29 April 2018
2013

Keplinger Diamond Bar

Sierra Foothills · Fair Play

How in the name of all that's holy is anyone getting any flavor or semblance of the varietal out of this wine is beyond me. Constricted, astringent, and bitter as the day is long. This needs more…

Reviewed 13 March 2018
2012

Favia Syrah Quarzo

Sierra Foothills · Amador County

Previous notes apply. Not as tight as nearly two years ago, but only moderately as complex or deep as I would have preferred. Some interesting purple fruit flavors, but the floral (Viognier)…

Reviewed 16 December 2017
2010

Aratas Petite Sirah Shake Ridge

Sierra Foothills · Amador County

Notes of black raspberry, wild blackberry, green and black olive, green peppercorn, and some mossy wet black slate. A little bit funkafied, with a clipped and clunky finish. It was ok, but a somewhat…

Reviewed 18 October 2017
2012

Pruett Vineyards Syrah Championship Cuvee

California · Sierra Foothills

Same as all of my previous notes. Drinking great now. Decanted, but it didn't need it. In a good window currently. Drink now and over the next 3+ years.

Reviewed 18 September 2017
2012

Pruett Vineyards Syrah Taylor's Reserve

Sierra Foothills · Placer County

Same as my notes 2 months ago. A decent, yet somewhat forgettable Syrah. Not as much verve or depth as I would have preferred. Drink now.

Reviewed 26 May 2017
2012

Pruett Vineyards Syrah Taylor's Reserve

Sierra Foothills · Placer County

Man, some folks are absolutely loving this wine right now. A few in our party killed this bottle almost instantly. I continue to find it more and more middle of the road as time goes on. It was super…

Reviewed 18 March 2017
2012

Pruett Vineyards Syrah Taylor's Reserve

Sierra Foothills · Placer County

All previous notes apply. This was tasted next to a 2012 Boich Cabernet GIII and a 2013 Myriad Cabernet, which both bested the Pruett. Not exactly a fair fight.

Reviewed 1 November 2016
2012

Pruett Vineyards Syrah Taylor's Reserve

Sierra Foothills · Placer County

Still about the same as my notes from last year. A very well-made Syrah, especially for the price-point. Not sure time will really move this into any further significant or elevated flavor profile;…

Reviewed 21 October 2016
2012

Keplinger Diamond Bar

Sierra Foothills · Fair Play

Tight and totally balled-up through the entire 4+ hours of tasting (decanted in a wide-bottomed decanter for most of that time at 54 degrees - warming it up in the glass to more room temperature…

Reviewed 10 September 2016
2010

Keplinger Sumo

Sierra Foothills · Amador County

PnP with high-toned notes of violets, grass, stone, bitter blackberries, and some blue fruit. Three total hours in the decanter didn't help to evolve this much.

Reviewed 10 August 2016
2012

Pruett Vineyards Syrah Championship Cuvee

California · Sierra Foothills

Same as my notes from 1/18/2016. Good solid Syrah. Impeccably balanced with a silky texture and nice core fruit flavors.

Reviewed 4 May 2016
2012

Favia Syrah Quarzo

Sierra Foothills · Amador County

Notes of huckleberry, purple/red plum, ollalaberry, pulverized granite, faint vanilla bean, and some residual alcohol. Nothing hollow, filling the mid-palate nicely, but just a tad shy on the back…

Reviewed 30 March 2016
2012

Pruett Vineyards Syrah Championship Cuvee

California · Sierra Foothills

PnP with dark blackberry, black cherry, raspberry, red licorice, and granite dust. Coming off a little overly fruity this time around after the initial popping of the cork. With more time in the…

Reviewed 18 January 2016
2012

Keplinger Sumo

Sierra Foothills · Amador County

A vibrant magenta color, with a bit of a muted nose; some alcohol on the first whiff, with not much fruit/berry aromas detected.

Reviewed 7 January 2016
2012

Pruett Vineyards Syrah Taylor's Reserve

Sierra Foothills · Placer County

PnP with reserved notes of dark berry, black currant, plum, chocolate, anise, and faint vanilla. After about two hours in the decanter, some nice mocha and licorice notes emerged.

Reviewed 29 October 2015
2009

Favia Syrah Quarzo

Sierra Foothills · Amador County

Started off with chalky, slate-driven tannins that initially cloaked some of the fruit and spice nuances. After a total of two hours+ in the decanter, this really came out of its shell, with black…

Reviewed 27 September 2015
2013

Keplinger Lithic

Sierra Foothills · Amador County

Tasted with DJ Warner at Keplinger in Saint Helena alongside the 2013 Sumo and the new 2013 Mars (to be released January 2016).

Reviewed 18 September 2015
2013

Keplinger Sumo

Sierra Foothills · Amador County

Tasted with DJ Warner at Keplinger in Saint Helena alongside the 2013 Lithic and the new 2013 Mars (to be released January 2016).

Reviewed 18 September 2015