Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

338 notes

2018

David Leclapart Champagne Premier Cru Cuvée L'Aphrodisiaque

Champagne · Premier Cru

On first pop, this is a powerful and almost brutish showing, with an angularity and pushy posture that makes that extra 1% of alcohol (listed at 13.5%) seem like a shot of Wild Turkey. Fear not…

Reviewed 27 November 2024
2019

Westborn Sparkling Rosé

California · North Coast

Westborn inaugural launch party, Brasswood, St. Helena. Three wines featured:

Reviewed 10 November 2024
2019

Westborn Brut

California · North Coast

Westborn inaugural launch party, Brasswood, St. Helena. Three wines featured:

Reviewed 10 November 2024
NV

Westborn Perpetual Reserve 01

California · North Coast

Westborn inaugural launch party, Brasswood, St. Helena. Three wines featured:

Reviewed 10 November 2024
2016

Paul Bara Champagne Grand Cru Brut Millésimé

Champagne · Grand Cru

Smells like the Pillsbury Doughboy got caught in a powdered sugar snow storm and was buried under a mound of maple confection. On the palate, the delivery is unsurprisingly sweet and slightly…

Reviewed 2 November 2024
2017

David Leclapart Champagne Premier Cru Cuvée L'Aphrodisiaque

Champagne · Premier Cru

Well, well, well. This performed exceptionally well, with its flawless combination of power, acidity, profundity, depth, energy, and layered flavor profile. This bottle really did everything right…

Reviewed 27 October 2024
NV

Krug Champagne Brut Grande Cuvée Edition 169eme

France · Champagne

A wine like this makes me wonder why I bother trying to hunt for all these other different Champagne. Variety is the spice of life and all that, but this right here is such a solid operator every…

Reviewed 21 October 2024
2019

Vilmart & Cie Champagne Premier Cru Grand Cellier d'Or

Champagne · Premier Cru

After having this a few times now, I ultimately think this is just too round and doughy for me. The balance and delivery are sound, as is the body, but the core fruit is masked by what seems to be…

Reviewed 10 October 2024
NV

Krug Champagne Brut Grande Cuvée Edition 169eme

France · Champagne

Hard to find fault here. Continues to improve each year. The 2013 vintage base has made for a stellar Champagne that simply has wonderful intensity, a complex and ever evolving menagerie of flavors,…

Reviewed 21 September 2024
2012

Marguet Sapience

Champagne · Premier Cru

A contemplative and dimensional wine, trading some of its would-be vibrancy for more serious bass tones. Poetry (Robert Frost.or rather Edgar Allan Poe) in a bottle vs. a Pitbull party in a bottle.…

Reviewed 20 September 2024
2018

Marguet Champagne Grand Cru Les Beurys

Champagne · Grand Cru

I thought this was a fantastic showing. I initially wondered if my score was slightly inflated, but this bottle was truly a standout and deserves recognition. Green and yellow apple notes intermingle…

Reviewed 16 September 2024
NV

Westborn Perpetual Reserve 01

California · North Coast

2020 base. 50%/42%/8% Chardonnay/Pinot Noir/Pinot Meunier. 4g/L dosage. "Perpetual reserve" (NV) from a project that started in 2018. Vineyards from "Northern California. Sonoma, Napa, Mendocino,…

Reviewed 2 September 2024
2018

Marie-Courtin Champagne Présence

France · Champagne

Last bottle of this and a quick final note just to put a period on all the other previous notes.

Reviewed 12 August 2024
NV

Bollinger Champagne Brut Rosé

France · Champagne

Superficial and high riding watermelon and white rock notes. Depth is missing here, though it does provide some satisfactory pick-me-up freshness that would at least compliment certain fare (for…

Reviewed 5 August 2024
NV

Laurent-Perrier Champagne Ultra Brut

France · Champagne

I didn't catch the disgorgement date, but it was very recent, perhaps painfully so. This is steely and pretty angular. It carries nice zip and is a refreshing enough aperitif type of sipper, but it…

Reviewed 5 August 2024
2018

Ultramarine Sparkling Rosé Heintz Vineyard

Sonoma County · Sonoma Coast

A consistently solid Rose from Ultramarine that I've reviewed a number of times now, it spits out red raspberry, Aperol, watermelon, strawberry, and river rock notes that offer waves of fruit flavor,…

Reviewed 3 August 2024
2002

Dom Pérignon Champagne P2

France · Champagne

I'm a huge fan of this P2's ability to energize the palate with a singular and focused thrust of fruit and mineral elements with such precision. The freshness and exactitude of its flavor expansion…

Reviewed 31 July 2024
2013

Dom Pérignon Champagne

France · Champagne

With some time to dive deeper with another at-home test on this wine, I'm finding I very much appreciate Dom in racier and more focused vintages, to which I believe the long and cooler growing season…

Reviewed 29 July 2024
2007

Billecart-Salmon Champagne Cuvée Elisabeth Salmon

France · Champagne

My notes on this read, "Bright, linear, and higher register than the other non-Rose Champagnes in the lineup. Notably less complex, with a straight shot of strawberry water and chalk on the slightly…

Reviewed 25 July 2024