Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

2,570 notes

2015

Promontory

California · Napa Valley

A perfect wine, and perhaps the best wine of the weekend. Black fruit profile (my favorite!), with dark spice, and black rock, black soil, black roses?!, black-black whatevers, bitter black…

Reviewed 6 June 2023
2018

Colgin Cabernet Sauvignon Tychson Hill Vineyard

California · Napa Valley

Saturating, juicy, delectable, and all the superlatives you can conjure up to describe what is indeed the most giving of the bunch. Heightened complexity is temporarily on hold during the initial…

Reviewed 2 June 2023
2018

Promontory

California · Napa Valley

Though the oak here is perceptible, it does not show as aggressively as Harlan on the initial pull of the cork. Earth, eucalyptus (or is it bay leaf?... or is it mint??), grippy unripe blackberry and…

Reviewed 2 June 2023
2016

MacDonald Cabernet Sauvignon

Napa Valley · Oakville

Speaking of proper service, having this wine a couple of weeks ago and having it again now just shows how important knowing (or attempting to target) a wine's sweet spot in terms of air, temperature,…

Reviewed 2 June 2023
2018

Harlan Estate

Napa Valley · Oakville

At first pass, this is a crunchy unripe black cherry covered in salty sawdust. I recall having that "Uh-Oh" feeling, wondering, "What wine is this? Did someone throw in a pirate here??" It doesn't…

Reviewed 2 June 2023
2016

Vice Versa Cabernet Sauvignon The Magnificent Seven

California · Napa Valley

Black earth, soil, black cherry, blackberry, and a slight vanillin chocolate note, this was the most succulent and deep wine in the lineup. It shows cascading opulence without being overdone. The…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

Colgin Cabernet Sauvignon Tychson Hill Vineyard

California · Napa Valley

Juicy and rich, with black fruit dominating the profile, the Colgin Tychson was quite the giving specimen. I suspected it might be a Colgin, but went with believing it was the M7 (erroneous as that…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

Eisele Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon

California · Napa Valley

Red and black fruit, expressive but tannic on the back end, finishing dry but not without requisite flavor and length. With air, the layering continued, though it was a bit unresolved and slightly…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

BOND St. Eden

California · Napa Valley

Deep and rich, but with a black fruited and mineral cut that starts out angular but quickly moves into a nice combination of grippy and giving. This is an interesting wine in that it starts out…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

Colgin IX Estate

California · Napa Valley

Compared to wine before it in the lineup (which was a red-"fruited" [mostly tannic] Abreu Thorevilos), this was all about black fruit, bitter chocolate, and black minerality. Did I mention black?…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

Abreu Thorevilos

California · Napa Valley

Red, powerful, tannic, and dry, with a woody finish that makes for an arid exit. A salty olive brine note adds to the initial feeling of astringency. With air, menthol, gravel, and unripe red cherry…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2019

MacDonald Cabernet Sauvignon

Napa Valley · Oakville

This was not part of the blind tasting of 2016 Napa Cabs, but of course, and you know how these things go, due to the continuing graciousness of our hosts, this 2019 MacDonald found its way into the…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

Futo Oakville

Napa Valley · Oakville

An awesome combination of fresh and brooding. I love the interplay of flavors here, with blackberries and purple plums dancing with the black minerality and meaty saline notes. I waffled between…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

MacDonald Cabernet Sauvignon

Napa Valley · Oakville

On first pass, and during the blind portion of this tasting, this presents as somewhat reduced, with muted fruit; it shows as both rounder and drier on the finish (if that's possible?). Shy red fruit…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2016

Scarecrow Cabernet Sauvignon

Napa Valley · Rutherford

This was the first wine in the tasting that seemed less uptight and unyielding. Here, a plushness and savoriness shows. A bit fruity at first, but with a textual seamlessness that seems to indicate a…

Reviewed 1 June 2023
2022

Kinsman Eades Chenin Blanc Aberro

Napa Valley · Diamond Mountain

There's a noble nose on this Chenin that sports a whiff of the exotic at first, but then rolls right into freshly cut honeydew, warm honey, and even the slightest hint of petrol aromas. It smells…

Reviewed 5 May 2023
2019

La Pelle Cabernet Sauvignon Alluvium

Napa Valley · St. Helena

Another go-around with this wine, which delivered the initial hit of powerful tannins, but was able to find a nice groove once given a healthy amount of air. This bottle kicked out super dark, black…

Reviewed 30 April 2023
2016

Roam Cabernet Sauvignon Sleeping Lady Vineyard

Napa Valley · Yountville

A very plush rendering of Sleeping Lady, with mocha, blueberries, blackberry cobbler, milk chocolate, vanilla, and sweet cassis, the 2016 Roam is succulent and round, with an easily accessible…

Reviewed 30 April 2023
2012

Araujo Estate Cabernet Sauvignon Eisele Vineyard

California · Napa Valley

This was a bottle purchased at the restaurant (Thanks again Bill!). It was very good and, with some time and air (two things that were kinda lacking at the time the bottle came to the table), it…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2021

Harlan Estate

Napa Valley · Oakville

As Cristal2000 covers thoroughly in his notes, this barrel sample highlights a chiseled restraint and wonderful purity. Beyond that, it rides high and tight, with bright red fruit popping on to the…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2017

Bella Oaks Vineyard Proprietary Red

Napa Valley · Rutherford

I don't want to fall in love with 2017s. I don't even want to fall in like with 2017. In fact, I want to love 2017s as much as I love 2020s, or even 2011s for that matter. If I have to hear one more…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2018

Promontory Penultimate

California · Napa Valley

Black currant, unripe black cherry, and a hit of sour berry flavors lead off the charge on the 2018 Penultimate. It stayed tight and a bit wiry on the first pop of the cork, but it became much more…

Reviewed 7 April 2023
2019

Keplinger Cabernet Sauvignon Vine Hill Ranch

Napa Valley · Oakville

I've ripped through a number of versions of VHR from most of those producing wine from this site and have found them to vary quite a bit depending much upon what I believe to be the winemaker's…

Reviewed 7 April 2023