Wine Doctrine
Every tasting note

Reviews

262 notes

2016

Château Fortin Plaisance

Libournais · Saint-Émilion

Black currant, black and red cherry, leather, cedar, and some earth. Lighter weight, with a watery mouthfeel and an alcoholic-laced delivery that makes for a bit of an awkward execution. It's not a…

Reviewed 23 October 2019
2016

Château Meyney

Médoc · Saint-Estèphe

Wild dark berry fruit, black soil, black rocky scortched earth, mocha, and some sappy cassis. Quite the mouthful on initial entry, but some nicely executed red and black cherry and dark raspberry…

Reviewed 22 October 2019
2016

Vieux Château Palon

Libournais · Montagne-Saint-Émilion

Very similar to a Meyney served beside it, with ripe, dark berry fruit heading up the front end delivery. Deep and saturated by Bordeaux metrics and perhaps a bit of an abomination by purist…

Reviewed 22 October 2019
2016

Château La Prade Francs Côtes de Bordeaux

Libournais · Francs Côtes de Bordeaux

So what's worth noting here is the QPR at $17 bucks. For what it delivers, it's stupid not to have a stash in hand for your friends that could give a crap about wine, but you don't want to suffer by…

Reviewed 21 October 2019
2016

Château La Fleur Peyrabon

Médoc · Pauillac

Red and black currant, tobacco leaf, subtle spice, and some earth, this delivers some decent flavors but can't hit the target on weight and depth. Finishes with lingering alcohol that further stomps…

Reviewed 21 October 2019
2016

Château d'Aiguilhe

Libournais · Castillon Côtes de Bordeaux

Plump blackberry, red and black cherry, chocolate, and some mocha. A bit of earth circles around the core. A slight tinge of alcohol on the finish, but otherwise a giving and ample base rate…

Reviewed 20 October 2019
2015

Château Troplong Mondot

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

Bordeaux vs. Tuscany vs. USA:

Reviewed 19 October 2019
2015

Château Pavie Macquin

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

Bordeaux vs. Tuscany vs. USA:

Reviewed 18 October 2019
2016

Château Pavie Macquin

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

This took about 2-3 hours of decanted air to fully open up. Wild blackberry, red and black cherry, red and purple plum skin limestone, muddled strawberry seed, and violets. A near-perfect combination…

Reviewed 15 October 2019
2015

Château d'Aiguilhe

Libournais · Castillon Côtes de Bordeaux

Blackberry, red and black cherry, mocha, coffee grounds, spice, and a floral note. Round and fairly plush on entry, with a really nice cut that grips everything all in the right place. Finishes…

Reviewed 15 October 2019
2016

Château de la Dauphine Fronsac

Libournais · Fronsac

Surprisingly powerful for such a base model Bordeaux. Some booze and a fairly dusty tannic spine needed some air to shake off a bit of astringency on the initial Coravin pour. However, once it…

Reviewed 14 October 2019
2015

Château Quinault L'Enclos

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

A noticeable step up from some of the $25-ish range Bordeaux served alongside it, with better focus and grip than some of its lesser comrades. Though with the $40+ price tag comes a little more…

Reviewed 12 October 2019
2015

Château Ferran Pessac-Léognan

Graves · Pessac-Léognan

Red and black currant, plum, and the typical cedar-spice-earth trifecta that lets you know it's a Bordeaux. It was a fine wine, but a bit thinner mid-palate than I had anticipated. I was hoping that…

Reviewed 12 October 2019
2015

Château Joanin Bécot

Libournais · Castillon Côtes de Bordeaux

Black and red cherry, sour plum, muddled strawberry, and some limestone. Wound up pretty tight at this juncture, keeping a linear trajactory most of the way through delivery. Finishes fuzzy and…

Reviewed 12 October 2019
2015

Château Dalem

Libournais · Fronsac

Very similar to the 2016, except that the 2015 was a little less rich (contradictory to the general vintage expressions in Bordeaux - where the 2015s overall seem to have a little more girth and…

Reviewed 11 October 2019
2015

Château Haut-Bailly

Graves · Pessac-Léognan

Linear and straight-laced from beginning to end. A stack of seeming potential, but not showing a full pulse until 7+ years from now. Similar to a '16 SHL I had the other day, with a primary delivery…

Reviewed 9 October 2019
2016

Château Smith Haut Lafitte

Graves · Pessac-Léognan

Much more linear and red-fruited at the moment when directly compared to the more unctuous and concentrated 2015 SHL, this 2016 displays red raspberry, red and black cherry, menthol, sage, and subtle…

Reviewed 8 October 2019
2002

Château Gruaud Larose

Médoc · Saint-Julien

Plum, black currant, leather, macerated black cherry, and wet cedar soil. Medium and graceful, but with a beautiful wrapping of subtle acidity that gently grips the dark fruit with a politely…

Reviewed 2 October 2019
2016

Château Beausejour (Duffau Lagarrosse)

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

Purple plum and plum skin, wet limestone (almost like the inside of a cave), black cherry, and spicy hints of white pepper smoked paprika. Smooth and remarkably balanced for such a primary delivery…

Reviewed 19 September 2019
2015

Château Troplong Mondot

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

Black currant, blackberry, fresh black soil, dark mulch, black cherry, clove, Christmas spices, burnt embers, and some pencil lead. A beautifully black and hauntingly earthy core, with a perfect push…

Reviewed 17 September 2019
2015

Clos l'Église (Pomerol)

Libournais · Pomerol

Red and purple plum, wet limestone, cassis, and some chalk. Grippy and hyper-focused, with a high register delivery that still manages to stay the course and provide a decent amount of flavor…

Reviewed 15 September 2019
2016

Château Fleur Cardinale

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

PnP was linear and primary, with black and some red berry fruit. Into the decanter it went for a total of three hours. Muuuuuch better... with blackberry, bitter chocolate, black cherry, black…

Reviewed 12 September 2019
2015

Château Haut-Batailley

Médoc · Pauillac

Red and black cherry, dark wild cranberry, rose pedals, white pepper, and some bitter bark. Keeps the overall delivery at a higher register, with a somewhat bitter plum skin note dominating on the…

Reviewed 11 September 2019
2016

Château Barde-Haut

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

Thank the holy Gods of the grape, this 2016 is WAY better than the 2014 I had yesterday. What a difference a vintage makes. Compared to the diluted 2014, this 2016 shows fulfilling red and black…

Reviewed 10 September 2019
2014

Château Barde-Haut

Libournais · Saint-Émilion Grand Cru

Soft plum, red cherry, leather, and some cedar. Thin and lithe on the attack, with a watery mid-palate. Finishes fairly flaccid, with the muddled plum note repeating on the back end.

Reviewed 9 September 2019